text / Yujie
likes to be in the front, but the wonderful is always behind
Thank you for your attention, like, favorite
" hidden in the dust " is true? Many are positive.
But I grew up in the countryside, and when I watched this movie, I had a strong sense of unreality and separation. After comparing
with the real situation in the countryside, I found that there are huge logical loopholes in the whole plot, which is why many people question that it is out of reality.
One of the most serious loopholes is that people who have strong skills can't set up!
The hardships of the middle-aged men described by Lu Xun have the premise of suffering from tuberculosis.
But in peaceful times, Ma Youtie has skills and thoughts, is healthy and hardworking, and is even gentle and considerate to his daughter-in-law. Not only is he not welcome to the villagers, he can't even afford to eat an egg.
To tell the truth, in the countryside, poor people, poor people, people who don't get married and work for others without self, some of them are very normal.
But these people have some problems more or less, whether it is human, or physical or mental problems, so they create their own sorrow.
But Ma Youtie is not like this, he is so perfect! So perfect that it seems that his grief is all the fault of circumstances.
But in fact, the countryside is a society of personal feelings. They will not be indifferent to people for no reason. This is not because the farmers are simple in nature but practical needs, which we will explain later.
So as long as Ma Youtie is not portrayed so perfectly, let him find a reason to be hated like Kong Yiji in character, or if he has a physical illness, or his mind is unclear, or he is seriously ill, everyone will not feel that something wrong.
, but the director gave Ma Youtie's character as a marginal person in society, honest, dull, and not sociable.
But in the countryside, there are too many such people, they may be ignored and ridiculed, but in the absence of any other character flaws, they are disliked and isolated to the point where their nephew gets married and does not invite him to the wedding, and when his wife dies, no one is there. The level of condolence is ridiculous.
In the final analysis, suffering will not find people for no reason, it needs a reason, whether it is the cause of the times or a personal flaw. Another serious loophole of
is that the director did not understand the social structure of the countryside at all, and portrayed the villagers too indifferently based on his own subjective wishes and the needs of his works.
You must know that the countryside is not a city, it is full of human feelings, and people without human feelings can't get along well here. Because the countryside is not as perfect as the city, all kinds of services are perfect. people help.
So even if the villains are small and wicked, the stumbling blocks take advantage, the Zhang family speaks ill of the Li family, and the Li family chews the Zhang family's tongue... that's all behind the scenes.
put it on the bright side, if you encounter major events such as building a house, weddings and weddings, as long as there is no serious conflict, you will completely cut off communication. If you look up and see you in the village, you will still help if you need to help, and you will still meet if you need to bow. Li, you won't do things like this.
is like Ma Youtie, no one helps when building a house, and when his wife dies, he does the funeral by himself. What
hit was not his Ma Youtie's face, but the face of his entire Ma family.
not to mention that his brother didn't invite Ma Youtie on the occasion of his son's marriage, which is ridiculous.
Unless the two of them don't get along with each other, or he abuses his own brother like this, it will not only be easy for outsiders to make irresponsible remarks, but also be criticized by the elders of the family.
doesn't even have such a sense of sophistication, it's impossible for his brother to gain a foothold in the village.
Looking at the whole movie, the only thing that is true is probably the rural environment and working methods.
Therefore, rather than saying that "Hidden in the Dust" is a work that reflects the real face of the rural bottom people today, it is better to say that it is a work that uses an old suffering story from the 1970s and 1980s to earn tears and banknotes.
- end
love life, love stories, love things you don't know.
More great stories on the homepage.
