online novel " Ghost Blowing the Lamp " is an excellent literary work, no matter how the so-called mainstream literature views it, its status is beyond doubt. The film and television drama works that use it as an IP are even more popular. After saying goodbye to some shoddy initial works, the Jin Dong and Chen Qiaoen versions of "The Ancient City" opened a precedent for sophisticated production. Over the past few years, whether it is the text or the extras, all the classics.
For the needs of distribution, several TV dramas have rationalized the scriptwriting of the novels on the premise of respecting the original work, but the character design of "Ghost Blowing Lamp" Iron Triangle Hu Bayi , Fatty Wang , Shirley Yang set to change. Readers who are familiar with the novel have also caused controversy about the actors in the Iron Triangle. Some think that Jin Dong's version is in line with the original work, and some think that , Pan Yueming, and are the image of Hu Bayi in their hearts. I personally think that Hu Bayi, played by Jin Dong, is more in line with the original novel. In the original novel by
, Hu Bayi came from a family of soldiers and participated in battles. After meeting Fatty Wang, he went to the capital to develop. I don't like to live a static life, and I don't like to be bound by material things. I am bold and careful, careful, and without losing my good nature.
The first impression of Hu Bayi in the novels we saw was "reliable". He is neither impatient nor impatient, and although he is anxious about life, he has never changed his thinking and character because of financial difficulties. The craftsmanship handed down by his ancestors did not "carry forward" for him here. He walked all the way without danger, and it was more about the calmness under his own life experience.
in Jin Dong's "Essential Ancient City", his image is very in line with Hu Bayi's established personality, and also in line with Hu Bayi's appearance in our minds. The only thing that is lacking is that Hu Bayi's Jianghu Qi is slightly lacking, and the actor has collected that energy a little bit.
has to admire the selection vision of the crew here. In "The Ancient City of Perfection", the actor of Fatty Wang makes up for Hu Bayi's shortcomings in Jianghu Qi. There is some reckless character in his righteousness, and his optimistic attitude with broken mouth and broken hands neutralizes Hu Bayi's rigidity.
Pan Yueming played Hu Bayi in several episodes, which is the exact opposite of Jin Dong's version. It is too suitable for Hu Bayi's Jianghu temperament, and Mr. Pan's image has some meaning of "literati acting in Jianghu". It always makes me feel a little awkward. When
arrived in the drama " Kunlun Shrine ", Hu Bayi's problem became even more obvious. For example, in the process of looking for a guide on the grassland, he encountered an injured female hygienist. The kind of self-blame and melancholy suits Pan Yueming very well, which makes people move. However, in the next step, they went to the Kunlun Shrine to explore the secrets. Under the circumstance of extreme weather outside, wolves around, many institutions, and uncle Ming and other unintelligent people inside, Teacher Pan did not interpret the strength of the original novel Hu Bayi. .
You have to know that in the original novel, Hu Bayi's response at a critical moment is very different from that in his daily life. In a critical moment, he will not be depressed because of emotional loss. He knows that it will kill more people. people. In the TV series, Hu Bayi gives the impression that he is very tired, very tired and very tired. It is not so much that he is exploring, it is better to say that he is fooling around with errands. Fortunately, in the subsequent plot, Mr. Pan, who played Hu Bayi, discovered this problem and relied on his excellent professionalism to recover.
One hero and three gangs, the reason why I think Pan's Hu Bayi is inferior to Jin's Hu Bayi, and another reason is that Fatty Wang is not good enough. After "Essential Ancient City", all the people in the Iron Triangle were replaced, and Fatty Wang was played by the familiar "Li Dazui". To tell the truth, the difference between his portrayal of Fatty Wang and the original novel is the biggest. In
's original novel, Fatty Wang is a hero who is not afraid of the sky and the earth, and does not depend on anyone. In "Kunlun Shrine" and the previous two films, Fatty Wang has been portrayed as a small follower of Hu Bayi, a A poor little gangster, a buffoon who only makes jokes. Of course, it may also be that the TV series weakens Fatty Wang and highlights Hu Bayi's needs.
and Shirley Young. Aside from some undiscussable factors, Xue Li Yang in the novel and Xue Li Yang in the TV series are very consistent. Whether it is Chen Qiaoen or Zhang Yuqi , they all act very well. A little flaw is that Zhang Yuqi's voice sometimes makes people play, but her atmosphere makes up for this lack. we know, Xue Li Yang in the novel is by no means a little jasper, but more like a man with a straightforward personality.
Under the dual contrast between the protagonist and the supporting role, it is reasonable for me to prefer Jin Dong's version of Hu Bayi to be more in line with the original novel. However, I can't belittle the follow-up series of "Ghost Blowing the Lantern", especially the recent "Kunlun Shrine". The actors, production, and plot are all excellent. In more and more garbage TV series, more and more songs should be played. It's not easy when novels, movies and TV dramas fill our spare time.
look forward to the next wonderful thing.
