Film review丨 "You are a teenager" a film with both obvious advantages and disadvantages

movie 1865℃
After

went around, the "Young You" was finally released on October 25. This movie is directed by Zeng Guoxiang, the director of "Qiandu" and "July and Ansheng", and played by Zhou Dongyu and Yi Qianqianxi. The current Douban score is 8.4.

This is a film with equally obvious advantages and disadvantages. The advantage of

is that director Zeng Guoxiang, as a native of Hong Kong, brought the most authentic town and college entrance examination atmosphere into the film. It is hard to imagine that a director who has never experienced the college entrance examination can portray the life of mainland teenagers so vividly. For example, after the mock exam, the whole class is rearranged according to the scores, and the entire class moves the tables and chairs; for example, bad teenagers play mahjong outside of school... The

movie also seriously involves the issue of "campus bullying". It is more serious and profound than Guo Jingming's claim to be "China's first novel to seriously discuss campus bullying" and "Sadness Going Upside Down", and the campus bullying involved in "Youth in Youth". For example, the "violators" headed by schoolgirls formed a small group. There were "active followers" and "passive followers" in the small groups. When the abused disappeared, the "passive followers" became the abused. Object.

Film review丨 'You are a teenager' a film with both obvious advantages and disadvantages - Lujuba

Zhou Dongyu's Chen Nian is the target of the assault. In desperate situation, she fumbled and pushed the assailant down the stairs. The

movie is not only about "campus bullying", but also family education. Both Chen Nian's mother and Xiaobei's parents played by Yi Qianqianxi are the ones who lack education.

And Dongyu Zhou also contributed quite good acting skills in this movie. Compared to her pure and pure in "The Love of Hawthorn Tree", the "quick and strange" created in series such as "July and Ansheng" "Personal Design", in "Youth in Youth", she further broke through her acting skills and contributed a variety of "crying" with different emotions in the film.

Film review丨 'You are a teenager' a film with both obvious advantages and disadvantages - Lujuba

From the beginning to the end, Zhou Dongyu had "cry scenes" almost from beginning to end. When she saw female classmates jumping off the building, getting into the trash can, talking to her mother, being cut off by Xiaobei, being interrogated by the police, and Xiaobei The back view when he was separated and defrauded by the police to Xiaobei's death sentence... Every crying scene is full of different emotions, and it is extremely complete and heartbreaking. I have to say that the director Zeng Guoxiang is really good at training people.

said so much about the advantages of "Young You", but this film is not without its disadvantages. Its shortcomings are more like the original sin of the script-the work "You are so beautiful" created by the author Jiu Yuexi scored only 6.4 points on Douban, and the biggest problem of this original work is "plagiarism" (industry Call it "Rong Jing").

"Fusion" is not someone else, but it is the famous Japanese writer Keigo Higashino's "White Night Walk", "Suspect X's Dedication", "Malicious" and other prestigious works.

Although the movie version of "Young You" has tried its best to bring the story back to small cities in China and arouse the resonance of more audiences, but because of the "original sin" of the script, the viewing experience of many audiences is fragmented.

Readers who have watched "White Night Walk" must know that when Ryoji and Xuesui met in the book, Ryoji missed his father because he witnessed Xuesui being insulted by his father, and Xuesui also witnessed the murder in order to protect him. Ryoji, the two had to remain anonymous and must cut off the relationship between the two. The classic relationship between the characters in the book-"symbiotic relationship", and the classic line-"I want to walk hand in hand under the sun" are all copied into the movie. In the

movie, Chen Nian and Xiaobei are also in a "symbiotic relationship". Their wish is "to walk in a small town with integrity" and "to study in Beijing together".

And Xiaobei, like Liangji in "White Night Walk" and the stone god in "Suspect X's Devotion", gave all of his own for the person who wanted to protect, so as to save another person to live a good life.

In fact, the core of such a story is Japanese. The Japanese emphasize the ultimate aesthetic (for example, giving everything to one person), which is relatively rare in Chinese stories. The youth of Chinese children is closer to the "dog ten three". Because of the plagiarism of the original author,

is a "setting" that the director and screenwriter cannot change anyway, resulting in a state of fragmentation in "Youth You". On the one hand, it is using extremely serious details to restore parts. The youth of Chinese teenagers, on the other hand, reminds people of some Japanese novels and film and television works from time to time, such as the aforementioned "White Night Walk", "Devotion of Suspect X", and "Malicious" (CampusBullying plot), "Confession", "For N" and so on. After the movie

was released, Douban's "You Are So Beautiful" book also appeared collectively with "one-star" comments that were not contemptuous of the author's plagiarism.

also said that because of the plagiarism problem in "You Are So Beautiful", no matter how good the movie is, it will not go to the theater to contribute to the box office.

The problem of "plagiarism" in Chinese literary works has been around for a long time. As early as ten years ago, Guo Jingming copied Zhuang Yu's "In the Circle and Outside the Circle" written in "How Many Flowers Fall in Dreams". Zhuang Yu has not received a single sentence so far. Apology, but "How Many Flowers Fall in Dreams" was a big hit, which further established Guo Jingming's popularity in the literary circle at that time. Later, "Sansheng III Shili Peach Blossom" copied the author's "Peach Blossom Debt", which was blown by the strong wind, but the original was a Danmei work and it was difficult to make it on the screen. Now, major websites, including the Jinjiang Literature City originally published in "You Are So Beautiful", are still strongly recommending this work, and there are still many unsuspecting audiences who "go here especially" to read "You Are So Beautiful" beautiful". There is a long way to go to protect and respect the copyright of

. Here I still want to say that Zeng Guoxiang is a good director, and I hope to be more cautious in choosing the script in the future. The good reputation of the original book will be destroyed because of the "plagiarism" problem of the original book.

Tags: movie