mentioned the Chinese military-themed TV series. Back then, " I am a special forces " starring Gu Zhixin , Xu Jia , Ren Tianye , etc., is definitely a landmark. This play is adapted from the novel "Leave Me the Last Bullet" by the young writer Liu Meng. In the play, the protagonist Zhuang Yan gradually grows from a local college student to an outstanding special soldier, which shows our army. The high-spirited and undaunted spirit of the middle-fighters and fighters in the grassroots units also shows the friendship of blood thicker than water among the comrades in arms. Once the show was broadcast, it quickly spread across the country, setting off a wave of military dramas throughout China, and directly attracted a large number of young people with dreams of military life to devote themselves to the fiery military camps.
pictures from the Internet
. Today, "I Am a Special Force" is still an insurmountable classic in the eyes of the majority of young people, especially military enthusiasts.
However, the layman looks at the excitement and the insider looks at the doorway. As a veteran who has been in the military for many years, especially a veteran who has dealt with a certain domestic special forces brigade many times, although "I am a Special Force" filming is youthful and passionate, it is still inevitable that the domestic TV series have many slogans and routines. conventional. More than ten years have passed. Looking back at this show, "I Am a Special Force" is obviously over-deified by the audience.
first talk about the irrationality of the character setting: Xiaozhuang, who has just joined the army, is unruly, can not see each other with the elder cannon of the squad, openly confronts the old cannon on the training ground, and even directly conflicts with the old cannon.
friends who have served in the army know that our army is a highly disciplined armed force. Starting from the first lesson of enlisting in the army, one of the concepts that is always instilled is "obedience! Absolute obedience!". What we emphasize is order and prohibition. Strict discipline is the fundamental guarantee of combat effectiveness. New fighters with personality and character like Xiao Zhuang (strictly speaking, they are thorns), it cannot be said that there are no, but they are definitely rare. Even if there are one or two, it won't be long before they will be cleaned up and obedient.
has a character that is not synonymous with thorns (the picture comes from the Internet)
Let me talk about the second point: Xiaozhuang is in the army for his girlfriend Xiaoying. In the era when the TV series were filmed, the distribution after joining the army was based on a random principle. Sometimes in a community, the small partners who joined the army together may go to Karakorum and the other to the coast of the South China Sea. To serve as a soldier for love... Ideals are beautiful, and reality is even more skinny! Wake up young man, maybe your love is blooming brilliantly under the kapok in the southern country, but you are leaping horses and whips in the snowy northern country beyond the Great Wall.
The protagonist’s love is very beautiful (the picture comes from the Internet)
In addition to the lack of character settings, the plot setting also has to complain: the author of
has been in the army for many years, and has also traveled as a grassroots reporter to many other brothers. Every unit, even every company, has its own unique character. But there is one thing that can basically form a commonality: those troops with strong combat effectiveness usually hide their fangs, and even gag and look like a group of huskies who commit two crimes, but once the critical moment is reached, one All of them are howling wolves! The fighting power is so powerful that it absolutely makes the enemy fearful! I have asked a lot of company chiefs, and the answers I got are basically the same-loose on the outside and tight on the inside. It’s better to seize the time to get a solid foundation! A group of cadres and soldiers are all right, shouting slogans? This group is passionate, but not in the second half!
Looking back at the Yehuo Reconnaissance Company where Xiaozhuang is located, various slogans shout loudly on the usual training ground, but at critical moments, the chain is always dropped. Among other things, Xiaozhuang is the famous thorn head of recruit company . He dared to hammer the squad leader and dared to train passively, and the whole regiment was registered. Lao Miao likes such soldiers. That's your own business, but if you bring this kind of thorn to a military training unit, you are not afraid of political cadres turning their faces? Well, you are the company commander and you have the final say, but you have brought the people back. What does it mean that the next group of squad leaders will not want this soldier? When can you pick and choose the task?
In addition, Xiao Zhuang and Chen Pai were separated during military exercises. In reality, if in the exerciseIn this situation, the first choice for a single soldier is to quickly return to the organizational system, especially in the field training, garrison training, sea training, and exercise phases. The accidental departure of personnel from the organizational system is a very serious safety accident in the grassroots units. To put it harder, some small exercises may stop immediately after reporting to the director's department. You Miao Lian dare to be so big as to wait for a platoon leader with a recruit to play a magical battle? Heart disease scared you out!
The poor old artillery was hammered by his own soldiers, and there is no one (picture from the Internet) After
Xiaozhuang entered the Spike Special Brigade, the entire Lone Wolf Group B was selected into the so-called "Special Forces in the Special Forces" 026 Logistic Warehouse (Logistic Warehouse said it doesn't carry this pot. Don't use me to hide your identity. During the war, my order of being hit is before you!)
I'm very curious about such a mysterious and important combat unit. Let a few rookies come in grandiosely? What about the good selections? What about choosing the best among the best ones? What about the king of soldiers?
As for Xiaoying to visit Xiaozhuang, that's even more nonsense. A key security unit, you are a small conscript who has no cadres to lead the team, and no letter of introduction from the unit. You just broke in with a lot of energy? Are there really bright posts, dark posts, detection posts, and mobile posts? The moment you enter the security area, you have been targeted. Once you enter the security line, you will wait to be investigated and written for inspection, and then the unit chief will lead you!
Okay, you are Mei Xiaohu. You have privileges. Comrade Sentinel is not strong in will, and my eyes are bewildered by beauty! So grandiosely you show affection with the protagonist in front of various leaders? Where is the courage of you two conscripts? "Chinese People's Liberation Army Disciplinary Regulations" is a decoration? Is such a high-profile show of affection for fear that Xiao Zhuang will not be punished? Three taboos within the army: petty theft, forming gangs, and messing around with men and women! Really fat!
In addition, Xiaozhuang was arranged to be undercover (active-duty PLA soldiers perform undercover tasks... The public security organs are helpless: Is this bullying us no one?), and he is still ambiguous with the daughter of the boss of the criminal gang! Comrade Xiaozhuang, what are your principles? Position? Really, you can get out of the military uniform when you go back! Although
is pretty, don’t be fooled by sugar-coated shells, Xiaozhuang! (The picture comes from the Internet)
As for the Lone Wolf Group B during its mission, the villagers were armed to resist the drug cartel, and I was even more powerless to complain. In the face of the formed special forces of the People’s Liberation Army, the drug dealers didn’t think about fleeing as soon as possible. The farther they escape, the better. They actually want to come back hard... Do these drug dealers have a lot of iron? Who is standing behind the troops? It is the entire People's Liberation Army and a powerful United Nations five permanent country! No country in the world can summon the courage to open this hell copy. This gang has not even come out of the Novice Village, and the mobs with incomplete clothing and armor want to head-on? Liang Jingru dare not watch you singing "Courage"!
As for armed villagers, it is even more impossible! The army has a complete set of plans and procedures to deal with emergencies. When the villagers are threatened, the first response is to evacuate the villagers, and then lie in ambush and wait for the door to be closed to beat the dog! Don’t say anything else, give out weapons and ammunition to the villagers...Don’t say you are the chief officer of a special force, just send a commander of a large military region over. Does he dare to make this decision? Are you not afraid of the loss of weapons and ammunition, and the criminals among the villagers taking the opportunity to do things?
After talking about the plot, let’s take a look at the clothing and weaponry:
stills (pictures from the Internet)
Spike’s special brigade wears a camouflage for the Army 03-style hunter. This camouflage uniform is dedicated to our army's special forces, which is true. But what does it look like when you put the hem of your clothes into the inner belt? Is it cool? "Chinese People's Liberation Army Internal Affairs Regulations" is a decoration?
Let's talk about weapons and equipment. From the above still picture, the ostrich uses a Type 85 sniper rifle. As a "strategic sniper" (what kind of a ghost term is this?), I don’t even have a 88 sniper rifle, ...Look at the assaultman: 95 assault rifle , 81-1 assault rifle... you want Is the logistics support unit exhausted?
A special combat team, there is no machine gunner! Who can suppress firepower? Rely on your slogans to kill the enemy? There is no 120 big tube, you have to match a 40 fire anyway, right? Face the enemyFort fortifications, throwing stones to death?
As for the vehicle...It is so simple that it can be used in 81-1. If you use the cheetah that saw off the roof, I won't say anything. What bobcat, what warrior, what warrior, too tall.
All in all, although "I Am a Special Force" is a beautiful-looking military-themed TV series, there are still many things that are divorced from reality. Those who really want to join the military camp can watch the excitement, but if you think of living a life in the military camp, let’s forget it. "Soldiers watch soldiers during the day and count the stars at night" is the norm in army life. The huge gap between reality and ideals will create a huge psychological gap. As for the reflection of this play among the audience, it is indeed deified.
