First of all, Yue Yunpeng is not a singer. He sings "Song of Peony" crookedly is just a burden, not the main content of cross talk performance. Just like Guo Degang sings "Flower Heart" and "Big Waist in Winter" crookedly, it is just a burden of cross talk performance. . Yue Yunpeng’s distorted singing accounts for a small proportion in cross talk performances, not the main performance part, so there is no infringement, just like a star talking about Yue Yunpeng’s small burden at a concert. If Yue Yunpeng's commercial performance "Yue Yunpeng Touring Singing Club-Song of the Five Rings", then Yue Yunpeng is undoubtedly an infringement, because he uses the melody of "The Song of Peony" as the main component of his performance, and therefore makes a profit, so this Be regarded as infringement.
Yue Yunpeng's only performance that may involve the copyright of "The Song of Peony" is the episode "Song of the Five Rings" he sang in the "Pancake Man" movie. The previous rap was written and performed by HOTDOG. There is no third-party copyright. The part of the chorus sung by Yue Yunpeng is the melody of "The Song of Peony", so it involves communicating with the copyright owner of the song of Peony and paying for it, and this song did not cause legal disputes, so it can be considered that both parties It was a consensus.
Tan Weiwei’s situation is completely different. She is a singer, and the adapted version of "Dare to Ask Where is the Way" is her performance at the Mid-Autumn Festival Gala, so Xu Jingqing, the composer, has the right to protest and question. Of course, whether Tan Weiwei is infringing or not is a matter of communication between the program and the team of Tan Weiwei and the copyright owner, and we will not judge here.
But to be sure, Tan Weiwei's adaptation and Yue Yunpeng's adaptation are two concepts, and they should not be confused.
In addition to the legal difference, the biggest difference between the two is that they are completely different in the attitude of the original author.
Yue Yunpeng himself said on a program that he communicated with teacher Jiang Dawei. At that time, it was Yue Yunpeng who asked Cai Ming to talk to Jiang Dawei about the copyright of "The Song of Peony". As a result, Jiang Dawei pulled down his face when he saw Yue Yunpeng and let him go. When we talked alone in the room, Cai Ming was also startled, thinking that Jiang Dawei was going to beat Yue Yunpeng. After entering, Jiang Dawei first seriously asked Yue Yunpeng a few questions. Did you change the "Song of the Five Rings" yourself? Why do I sing "Song of Peony" and the next group of people shouting five rings?
Last question: I have another song "A Place Where Peach Blossoms Bloom". Would you like to change it too?
Finally, Jiang Dawei said to Yue Yunpeng: Children sing as they please, change it by the way, it does not matter, this "Song of Peony" is even more popular, thank you for bringing me this!
Of course, Yue Yunpeng may have added some ridiculous elements, but it can be seen that he has carefully communicated with Jiang Dawei beforehand, and has been recognized and praised by the other party.
What Jiang Dawei didn't know was that his "The Place Where Peach Blossoms Bloom" has been changed to "The Place Where Chrysanthemums Bloom" by Guo Degang.
However, Tan Weiwei caused the controversy this time because the program, the adaptor and Tan Weiwei did not communicate with the copyright owner Xu Jingqing in advance. As the organizer, CCTV should conduct a full review of the program, including verification of copyright, otherwise it should not be broadcast at such a national evening party. The adaptor Guo Junjiang is also unidentified, and everything is a mess. Afterwards, Tan Weiwei apologized sincerely, and was also considered a dumping of the pot. He only said that he was not good at singing but refused to admit the infringement. Of course, this is also understandable. Originally, as a singer, her arranger has nothing to do with her, and copyright communication cannot be done by her, but all the saliva is directed at her, which is equivalent to a big pot alone. I think she can apologize sincerely, which is considered good. As for the result of the subsequent accountability, it depends on Xu Jingqing's attitude as the right party.
