On March 7, a reporter from Red Star News received a report from volunteer Shangguan Zhengyi, saying that the Huanghuai Judicial Identification Center in Zhumadian City, Henan Province had committed illegal acts of falsifying and replacing the identity of the person being identified in the paternity test. He suspected that illegal personnel were suspected of passing the internal Personnel launder the identities of adopted or even illegally trafficked children, thereby achieving legal settlement.
Identification materials show that Runan County couple Wang and Li conducted a paternity test with their child named Wang Ke at the center, and the test result was "support that Wang and Li are Wang Ke's biological parents." However, a Red Star News reporter's investigation found that the child actually identified was not "Wang Mooke", but the couple's biological son Wang Moucheng. There is currently no child named Wang Mooke on his family's household registration.
In the end, Wang and his wife admitted that they put their son Wang Cheng in a skirt to perform a blood test on behalf of "Wang Ke" when testing the paternity. However, they denied that Wang Cheng was adopted or trafficked, but was given up for adoption many years ago. The biological daughter who went out. As for why Wang Mouke was not allowed to do the appraisal himself, he explained that the child was not around at the time for convenience.
▲Photos retained in the forensic appraisal report
The person in charge of Henan Huanghuai Detection Technology Co., Ltd. said that the gender on the birth certificate provided by Wang and Li when they came for appraisal was girl. If the girl was replaced during the appraisal process, then This should be a matter of the person being appraised providing false identification materials.
On the afternoon of March 11, a Red Star News reporter went to the Runan County Health Commission. After checking the information, the staff confirmed that in Runan County, there was no birth of a child named Wang Ke under the names of Wang and Li. prove. In this regard, a Red Star News reporter has gone to the Zhumadian City Justice Bureau and reported the matter to the official department.
The household registration file shows that the couple has three children
The girl was identified as not among them
In Baimiao Community, Runan County, Zhumadian City, Henan Province, a Red Star News reporter visited the home of Wang and Li. Li said: "Our family There is no such situation. All three children are registered, and there is no child named Wang Mooke in the family."
Subsequently, the Red Star News reporter showed Li the photos in the appraisal report, and he admitted the photos after evading the words several times. The person in the photo is herself, but as to whether the "Wang Ke" in the photo is "Wang Cheng", Li kept looking around and did not give a clear response.
After a brief conversation, the other party urged the reporter to leave quickly, but just as he was leaving, three children returned home from school. Through careful observation, the reporter found that one of the boys was highly similar to the "Wang Ke" in the paternity test report. Although the "Wang Ke" in the report was wearing a skirt, his appearance and figure were almost identical.
▲Photo of Wang Moucheng
The elder (the second father of the three children) who picked up the three children home from school said: “There are only three children in the family, all of whom have birth certificates and registered residence. The three children are Wang. Nuo, Wang Moucheng, Wang Moulin." He denied the existence of "Wang Mouke" in his home.
html On March 9, the reporter did not find a girl named "Wang Mouke" settled in the existing household registration files of the community. Household registration files show that Wang and Li currently have three children in their names, namely Wang Nuo (female) born in 2014, Wang Lin (female) born in 2017, and Wang Mou born in 2019. Cheng (male).The father admitted to replacing the child during the appraisal
said that the child was not around for convenience
html On the afternoon of 09, a Red Star News reporter met Wang in the Baimiao community. After showing the photos of the scene taken during the appraisal, he admitted that the photos were of himself and his wife Li. , Regarding the girl’s identity, Wang Mou insisted that she was his youngest daughter Wang Mou Ke, and there was no imposter. "I gave birth to the child while I was working outside. Now I am at my cousin's house in Zhengzhou. Although the paternity test has been done, the household registration has not been registered yet."After the reporter presented the relevant test report and explained the stakes of the fake paternity test, Wang finally admitted that the "Wang Ke" in the photo was not him, but his youngest son Wang Cheng.He told reporters that the child was born when he was working in Hunan. At that time, there were many children in the family and he gave them away. However, he later took them back and raised them in a relative's house. Wang revealed that he asked someone from Huanghuai College to do the appraisal at that time, but he was not very clear about the specific fees. His relatives paid for it on his behalf.
"Now that the children are older and have to go to school, they asked me to apply for a household registration for their children. They found people from Huanghuai College through relatives." Finally, at the Henan Huanghuai Judicial Appraisal Center, the boy Wang Moucheng was put into a girl's skirt. , "a raccoon cat for a prince" replaced Wang Mouke's identity to complete the paternity test. Wang emphasized from beginning to end that Wang Ke was his biological daughter, neither bought nor adopted.
Since she is her biological daughter, why did she let her biological son do the paternity test on her behalf? In this regard, Wang explained that the child was in Zhengzhou at the time and it was not convenient for him to return to his hometown. After being notified by his family, he asked his son Wang Cheng to put on a skirt. Go to the Forensic Identification Center. The staff responsible for the identification did not identify the gender of the child. After taking pictures, drawing blood, and testing, finally on September 26, 2023, the Henan Huanghuai Judicial Identification Center issued the "Yuhuanghuai Judicial Identification Center [2023]" Document No. 471.
reporters saw that the identification report showed that Wang Mouke’s gender was female and her date of birth was 2020. The opinion given was: “Based on the existing information and DNA analysis results, it is supported that Wang and Li are Wang Mouke’s Biological parents." The identification date was September 22, 2023. The identification materials were blood samples of Wang, Li, and Wang Ke, and the appraisers were Hou Mouwei and Wang Mouhong.
▲ A report issued by the Henan Huanghuai Forensic Identification Center
An appraiser said he was not responsible for the specific work
There are specialized personnel to identify the identity
On September 7, 2022, the Henan Provincial Department of Justice released on the official website the "Forensic Clinical Identification of the Henan Huanghuai Forensic Identification Center" "Announcement on the Business Scope of Forensic Evidence Identification, Forensic Toxicology Identification and the Approval of Appraisers to Practice", the approved business scopes include: forensic clinical identification, human injury degree identification, human disability level identification, compensation-related identification, forensic evidence identification, triplet parent-child relationship Identification, doublet paternity identification, forensic poison identification, volatile poison identification (alcohol identification only).
In the paternity test reports of Wang, Li and Wang Ke, Hou Mouwei and Wang Hong both have "Forensic Appraiser Practice Certificates". On March 10, a Red Star News reporter went to the Henan Huanghuai Judicial Appraisal Center and found that the center was located at Huanghuai College in Zhumadian City, Henan Province. It can be found on the school's official website that Wang Mouhong is an associate professor in the school of biology and food engineering. He has taught at the school since 2004 and his main courses are "Microbiology" and "Fundamentals of Modern Biology".
The reporter also found a photo of Wang Mouhong on the teacher information wall of the School of Biology and Food Engineering of Huanghuai University, where he is an associate professor. When contacted by phone with the Henan Huanghuai Forensic Identification Center, the staff said that the center is located in Huanghuai College, but the name of the center at the scene was "Henan Huanghuai Testing Technology Co., Ltd."
▲The photo on the wall shows that Wang Mouhong is an associate professor at the School of Biology and Food Engineering.
The company’s honorary profile on the wall states that in August 2022, the company obtained the "Forensic Appraisal License" issued by the Henan Provincial Department of Justice. "Certificate", a photo of Associate Professor Wang Mouhong was also found in the team profile, as well as another appraiser Hou Mouwei in the appraisal report, whose position is deputy chief forensic physician. On the official website of Huanghuai College, the reporter noticed a report in 2020 that "Henan Huanghuai Testing Technology Co., Ltd. donated epidemic prevention and control materials to the school." The article stated: "Henan Huanghuai Testing Technology Co., Ltd. is a cooperative enterprise of our school. It is mainly responsible for third-party testing business, and its business scope includes food safety, environment, occupational health, radiation hygiene, etc.”
Red Star News reporter searched the Henan Huanghuai Judicial Appraisal Center through public information and found Henan Huanghuai Testing Technology Co., Ltd. Founded in 2014, its address is No. 6 Kaiyuan Road, Zhumadian City (inside Huanghuai College), and its phone number is the same as that of the Henan Huanghuai Judicial Identification Center.
html On March 11, a reporter from Red Star News contacted Wang Mouhong by phone. She said: "I am only serving as a forensic evidence. I will definitely need my cooperation during the identification, but the specific details are done by the company, not me." Regarding whether the appraiser needs to check the identity and gender of the person being appraised, Wang Mouhong said that he does not need to verify it himself. There are specialized personnel to do it. As for which link has the problem, he needs to ask the relevant staff.Runan County Health Commission:
There is no birth certificate of the child who was identified in the county
Red Star News reporter came to Henan Huanghuai Testing Technology Co., Ltd. and explained to the person in charge the paternity test report of Wang, Li and Wang Ke related issues. Manager Jia, the person in charge of the company, said that the gender of the birth certificates provided by Wang and Li when they came for identification was girl. If the girl was replaced during the identification process, it should be a problem of the guardian of the person being identified providing false identification materials.
Obviously the person being appraised should be Wang Mooke, but was replaced by Wang Moucheng. The gender is different. Why didn’t the appraisal center identify it? “If there is a problem, we bear full legal responsibility. If it is verified that anyone has collected their Money or anything else, you can do whatever you want with this person. If you should report it, report it. I will never defend it." Manager Jia said, "But whether the result of this report is false or not should be determined by experts organized by the relevant administrative departments of the Bureau of Justice. . If the expert identification is a false report, we will resolutely bear the responsibility we bear."
On the copy of Wang Mooke's birth certificate provided by the staff, the Red Star News reporter noticed that the gender column was female. On the afternoon of March 11, a Red Star News reporter went to the Runan County Health Commission. After checking the information, the staff confirmed that in Runan County, there was no birth of a child named Wang Ke under the names of the couple Wang and Li. prove.
▲Henan Huanghuai Detection Technology Co., Ltd.
A reporter searched for relevant documents and found that the Forensic Identification Administration Bureau of the Henan Provincial Department of Justice issued the "Notice on Strengthening the Management of Forensic Evidence Identification" on November 25, 2020, which clearly requires forensic identification The institution shall require the parties concerned to go to the judicial appraisal institution in person and collect the examination materials in the judicial appraisal institution. Adhering to the principle of personal experience of judicial appraisers, it is required that when the appraiser goes to the scene to collect inspection materials, he should show the "Forensic Appraiser Practice Certificate" to the parties and take photos (color photos) with them. The entire process of collecting inspection materials should be videotaped.
On December 29, 2020, the General Office of the Ministry of Justice issued the "Emergency Notice on Strictly Regulating the Work of Forensic Identification Agencies in Carrying out Paternity Testing Business", which requires judicial authentication agencies to videotape the entire process of verifying the identity information of the parties, and can use it if conditions permit. Face recognition, fingerprint recognition, etc. If the identity information cannot be verified, or if the verified identity information is doubtful, identification work shall not be carried out. Forensic identification agencies should require the parties to make a written commitment to the authenticity of the identity information. The judicial appraisal institution shall strictly implement the requirement that the parties concerned personally go to the judicial appraisal institution to collect examination materials. The minor's guardian must be present and confirm the identification.
Subsequently, the Red Star News reporter went to the Zhumadian City Justice Bureau and reported the matter to the official department. The receptionist told the reporter that they would hand over the reported issues to the relevant business departments for verification as soon as possible to understand the situation.
Red Star News Intern Reporter Zhong Mengzhe Reporter Luo Mengjie
Editor He Xianfeng Editor-in-Chief Deng Haoguang
