Han Xue sang the song "Growing Up with a Weight of 10,000 Jin" at the annual live broadcast night of "Chengfeng 2024", and defeated Joyce who sang the classic song "May People Live Longer" in Chinese.
Although Han Xue moved herself on the stage and sang to tears, the audience was not moved.
That night, the entry "Han Xue is ugly" became a hot search topic.
Probably because the netizens were mocking her too loudly, Han Xue couldn't bear it anymore. She posted a message saying, "Music aesthetics are free and we respect every netizen's listening and viewing experience. But in this song, the author conveyed the "pain" endured by the victim's body and soul. ". In any case, it should not become the material for ridicule and jokes. Please respect the author and the work, thank you!"
On the screenshot she posted, you can see the words "You still have grandpa".
did not expect that the comment area would be filled with netizens mocking her for not being able to afford it, making it difficult for even fans to control her comments. When the
program was first aired, many netizens complained about Han Xue's unsound song.
Because Han Xue changed several voices in one song, I don’t know whether it was to show off her skills or for some other reason.
It was very low-pitched at first, then suddenly picked up, then turned into a bel canto, and finally had a crying tone.
Netizens with venomous tongues summed it up at the time: "How did Han Xue transition from An Lingrong chanting sutras to Baojuan to Luo Tianyi cassette in one second?"
Some netizens felt that Han Xue was performing on the stage. A period of voice change.
As the complaints became louder and louder, Han Xue posted a post to tease netizens.
If you look at Han Xuefa's words alone, she is right. After all, there is a heavy story behind the song "Growing Up with a Weight of 10,000 Jin".
This song was inspired by the Korean movie "Sowon", which in turn was inspired by a real case.
Therefore, if some viewers really use this song or lyrics to make fun of and make jokes, of course it is inappropriate.
So, why do netizens express their dissatisfaction in Han Xue's comment area, thinking that she can't afford it, and that she is very smooth in changing the topic?
A comment with 45,000 likes believed that Han Xue was singing unpleasantly and not letting anyone complain. No one disrespects the original singer. Many celebrities have covered this song before, but no one said anything about it.
Han Xue was criticized by so many people after singing, she should think about why.
Another hot comment with 30,000 likes is more direct: No one is maliciously playing songs, isn't it because your singing is ugly?
To put it bluntly, in the eyes of netizens, there may be a small number of people making fun of Han Xue's grandfather, but the vast majority of people say that Han Xue's singing is unpleasant, so they feel that Han Xue is actually changing the concept. Even attempted moral kidnapping.
Some netizens believe that Han Xue's singing style is also disrespectful to the original song -
"I think it is disrespectful to the song to sing such a profound and serious song into a sticky bubble sound."
Among the many netizens who expressed similar views, one netizen made a very reasonable point. She asked Han Xue: "The belly is getting bigger and bigger" contains so many victims and so much despair. Why are you smiling so sweetly?
Because before listening to Han Xue's version, Sister Dao didn't know this song. When I saw Han Xue performing it with a smile, I thought this song was about the process of women growing from a girl to a mother.
thought that when Han Xue sang "The belly is getting bigger and bigger", she was thinking of her mother, so she smiled.
After understanding the background, I realized that it was not the case at all.
From this perspective, there is indeed something wrong with Han Xue's performance.
Of course, no matter what, it's okay to comment on the bad singing, but it's really not appropriate to make fun of family members.
However, I personally feel that Han Xue’s breach of defense was probably not just due to criticism from netizens.
In fact, on the night of the live broadcast, she was about to break because of the host's repeated kissing.
It should be said that although Han Xue's singing is unpleasant and her speech is a bit artificial, it is one thing for netizens to make fun of her. It is a bit too much for the host to deliberately make fun of her in front of others and make people unable to come off the stage.
After Han Xue finished singing, she made a joke by herself and said in a cooing voice that has been ridiculed on the Internet recently: Hello everyone, I am Han Xue, and I did it.
Host Liu Ye imitated: I want to bloom, bloom in my heart.
At this time, Han Xue was still in the mood to play with her and corrected her wrong lyrics.
But Liu Ye really had no sense of propriety and worked hard to drive "crazy" Han Xue.
After several teammates finished talking about their reactions, Liu Ye suddenly reached out and wiped Han Xue's tears with his fingers when he saw that Han Xue was still crying.
Han Xue took a step to the side obviously unhappy and avoided her hand.
While reading the hot search section, Liu Ye read a hot comment: It turned out that Han Xue’s voice was not fake.
After she finished reading, the camera cut to the viewing room, and the sisters' expressions were very exciting.
Although the comment she read later was from a netizen who said that she became a fan because of Han Xue's interesting voice, Han Xue's expression was obviously not happy.
is the same. Han Xue is a self-proclaimed talented actress, singer, and director. You said you like her because her voice is funny. Can she be happy?
Although Han Xue was very reluctant, it was a live broadcast after all. When Liu Ye asked her to respond, she could only respond with a forced smile.
She said that she did not get the joke at first because she has been talking like this for 40 years. I'm a little confused myself, and I hope everyone can get used to her voice.
Finally, he said generously: Just have a good time.
Even so, it can still be seen that Han Xue is a little concerned about this topic, and after saying her generous words, she can't stand it anymore.
felt like she was going to cry, but she couldn't cry, so she finally sat down with an aggrieved look on her face.
Mango is very aware that most of the hot searches during the live broadcast are black hot searches, but he still insists on executing this link because he is sure that the sisters will not lose their temper during the live broadcast.
I guess Han Xue felt very uncomfortable at that time. After the show, she became more and more angry and thought about it. She also saw so many comments saying that her singing was unpleasant, so she found an excuse to use the topic as an excuse.
Han Xue probably didn't expect that after she posted her statement "Don't make memes", not only did she not get much support, but the comment area of her own account was also downgraded.
You should know that unless it involves moral issues, netizens will mostly just make a few comments in their own accounts, and rarely go directly to celebrity accounts to make comments collectively. Even if there are a few
here and there, they will be controlled and suppressed by fans, rather than causing such an out-of-control mess.
Han Xue still doesn’t understand contemporary netizens.
The popularity on the Internet is fleeting. No matter how many people complain about "unpleasant", it will pass within a few days.
But she came out and spoke so righteously, and it seemed that she couldn't afford not to talk about it. It also inspired the rebellious psychology of netizens and made them laugh even more enthusiastically.
originally just said that her singing voice was unpleasant, but now it has become a "moral kidnapping", "blaming netizens", and "disrespecting the original singer".
Moreover, Han Xue's behavior will be remembered by netizens. If she participates in any program or has any negative news in the future, this paragraph will be used as a negative example. Why bother?
