January 2nd
music blogger @ acoustic theory
, who had reported Mayday’s lip-synching, released his own assessment of
Hunan Satellite TV’s New Year’s Eve party
’s true lip-synching
. In the article, he wrote: “This is the most painful time in my history. Identification, a large number of choruses, the larger the number of people, the shorter the stay time of each person is, the more difficult it is to judge. According to the recordings of the few real singers, there is a high probability that real-time tuning will be enabled at this New Year’s Eve party ."
According to his appraisal, such as Li Ronghao, Phoenix Legend, Chen Chusheng, Wang Yuexin, Jolin Tsai, Zhang Yuan, Wang Zhengliang, Chen Jiaye, Hua Chenyu, Wang Yaoqing, etc. are really singing . The identification stated that Li Xian, Yu Shuxin, Zhao Lusi, Yang Zi, Tan Jianci, Wang Yibo, Wang Hedi, Song Qian, Lu Yuxiao, Meng Huiyuan, mame group, Wei Daxun, Wang Qiming, Pu Sha, Qi Wei, Li Chengxuan, Times Youth League, etc. were lip-synching for .
He said that the opening show chorus was a mixture of real and fake, and for some songs, the chorus could not be identified, and the solos were all lip-syncing. Some singers such as Da Zhangwei, Huang Xiaoming, and Han Hong were suspicious. The original text of
is as follows:
#夜夜夜夜夜夜狠狠狠狠狠的valuation of Hunan Satellite TV:
The "Opening Show" of the Lively Good Six Group and Chengfeng Xiangqiang Group: a mixture of true and false.
"Sisters and Sisters Dance" by Liu Yiyun, Cheng Xiao, Li Sidani, Jin Chen, Yuan Yonglin, and Chen Bing: The chorus part cannot be identified, and the solo parts are all lip-syncing.
Li Ronghao "Model", "Li Bai", "Composer", "The King of Comedy", "Don't Give in", "Mom and Dad", "Quit Smoking", "Young and Promising", "Sparrow", "Wumeizijiang" 》: Real singing.
Zhang Tianai, Sun Yi, Qiao Xin's "Thunder Is on the Way to Hit You": There are doubts about the female singer in evening dress and the female singer in short skirt (she prefers to lip-sync), and the female singer in wedding dress lip-syncs.
Song Qian's "Sensory Control": According to my personal standards, doing it like this is lip-synching.
He Jiong and Xu Song's "Why Not": The chorus part cannot be determined, and He Jiong's solo part is doubtful.
Xu Song's "Clear Passing" and "Superfluous Explanation": Doubtful (more authentic singing).
Phoenix Legend "Lady Luxurious Fragrance" and "The Most Dazzling National Style": real singing.
"The Song That Never Ends" by Da Zhangwei and Wang Yibo: Da Zhangwei has a small pad, and Wang Yibo has a big pad. The latter is lip-syncing according to my personal standards.
Chen Chusheng's "Original Me": Real singing.
Chen Chusheng, Wang Yuexin, Zhang Yuan, Wang Zhengliang "Deserves It": True Singing.
Anna Yao "Go Where the Wind Is": Doubtful.
Li Xian's "When the Stars Shine": lip-syncing.
Yu Shuxin's "gwalla": lip-synching.
Xie Na, Chen Jiahua, Liu Yiyun's "Who is the mvp": doubtful (false).
Zhao Lusi "Crescent Bay": lip-synching.
Song Qian and Wang Hedi's "Roof on Fire": lip-synching.
Cheng Yi's "On the Rivers and Lakes" and "Tianya": the former one is questionable (false), and the latter one is lip-synced.
Yang Zi's "Sauvignon Blanc": lip-synching.
Era Youth League's "Love to 1440": In my personal standards, it's lip-syncing like this.
Qi Wei and Lee Seung-hyun's "Crazy Love": lip-syncing.
Wei Daxun's "Lanting Preface": lip-synching.
Da Zhangwei's "The Law of All Things Blooming": There is doubt, and it is suspected that true and false are mixed.
Tan Jianci's "The Unable to Wait" and "Mona Lisa": The first song is questionable (the main song is true, the chorus is false); the second song is lip-syncing, of course you can hear him shouting on the mic from time to time .
Huang Xiaoming and Chi Fu's "Rainbow Smile": There is doubt that Chi Fu is seriously biased.
Xie Na, Mario, Xiao Yuner's "My Paper Plane": real singing.
He Jiong, Wang Han, Times Youth League's "Float Show": the chorus cannot be identified.
Han Hong's "Millennium Promise": Doubtful.
Wang Yibo "The Spectator": In my personal standards, doing it like this is lip-synching.
Jolin Tsai's "Hot Winter", "Big Man", "Beautiful", "Madrid", "i'm not yours + dancer", "oh la la la": real singing.
Wang Hedi's "Shanlan": lip-syncing, and you can hear two shouts from time to time.
Wang Hedi, Wang Qiming, and Pu Sha's "Seaside Tango": lip-syncing.
Chen Jiahua's "Wish List", "Tropical Rainforest", "Super Star": real singing.
Cai Guoqing, Wang Yaoqing, Times Youth League's "Miracle Reappearance": Cai Guoqing and Wang Yaoqing are doubtful, and Times Youth League's chorus cannot be identified.
Hua Chenyu's "Sea of Wind" and "Ordinary to Extraordinary Life": real singing.
Phoenix Legend, Zhao Lusi's "It's All Love": Phoenix Legend really sings, but Zhao Lusi has doubts.
Wang Yaoqing's "Uncle Is Like This": really sung.
Cai Guoqing, Lu Yuxiao, Meng Huiyuan, mame group "365 Blessings": lip-synching.
A large number of people "Cross": lip-syncing.
...
This is the most touching and painful identification of true and false singing in history, otherwise there would not be so many "doubts". First of all, there are a large number of choral repertoires. The more people singing, the shorter the stay time of each person is, and the more difficult it is to judge. Especially the chorus part, there is almost no way to identify it.
In addition, according to the recordings of a few real singers, this Hunan Satellite TV New Year's Eve party will most likely have real-time sound modification enabled. In this way, the gap between the real and fake singing fields will not be so big, and the long-term Watching over time can lead to judgment fatigue and it is very easy to get confused. It can be said that this party has indeed updated and iterated the lip-synching technology through various methods, making identification more difficult. It’s really hard to put into words.
However, after its identification was released, many netizens questioned it, saying that its credibility was not high.
In addition, this morning this blogger also released the identification of the true and false singing of Dragon TV’s New Year’s Eve party. The original text is as follows:
#新年夜夜夜狠狠的综合综合# by Oriental Satellite TV:
Tengger’s “Invisible Wings”, “ "Love You", "The Sun Never Sets": doubtful (false); "Umeko-chan", "Outbreak of Courage": lip sync.
Su Xing and Lu Rover's "Daily Life of an Old Singer": Real Singing.
"Longli Electric Silk" by Su Xing, Lu Hu, Fu Longfei, Zhao Rang, and Xu Zimo: The rap part is really sung, but the melody part of the first part is doubtful (it should just be to turn on the effector).
wake up "rising land": real singing.
Zhang Xincheng's "The Look of Dreams": Real singing.
Su Huilun and Yang Kun "Every Day in My Life": Real singing.
Yang Kun's "Today is Your Birthday": Really sung.
Huang Minghao's "One Man": Lip-synching (no privileges for singing and dancing).
Huang Jingyu's "Going Against the Light": Doubtful.
Gong Jun "Tomorrow will be clear": Doubtful.
Huang Ling's "Wang Zhaojun": If it's a live performance, it's lip syncing; if it's a recorded performance, it might just be post-production.
Guangliang's "Fairy Tale": real singing.
A Niu's "Peach Blossoms Blooming": True singing.
Guangliang, A Niu and Ren Xianqi's "The Waves are Blossoming": real singing.
Zhang Qi's "Cage": real singing.
Jam Hsiao's "Your Name is on the Ring Finger" and "Can You Feel the Love Tonight": Real singing.
Zhan Wenting "Crescent Bay": Real singing.
Meiyi Liya and Teku's "Pure Land": real singing.
Zhan Wenting and Mei Yiliya's "Blue Bird": real singing.
Zhang Xinzhe's "Hanging" and "I Want to Love You Too Much": real singing.
Tian Xiwei and Cheng Lei's "Sweet": lip-syncing.
Huang Qishan and Man Shuke's "Towards the Clouds": real singing.
Huang Qishan's "My Beauty": Real singing.
Wang Zihao's "a·i.bae": lip-syncing.
boyhood "Round Landing": lip-syncing.
Angela Chang's "Flowers in Dreams" and "The Farthest Place Seen": real singing.
Yu Shi's "Long Memories" and "The Bridge of Tears": real singing.
Huang Bo's "Lin Sujuan": Real singing.
Huang Bo, Xiao Jingteng, Zhang Qi's "Drunk or Not Drunk Suite": real singing.
Zhang Ruoyun's "Push the Door to the World": doubtful (the pitch sounds like real singing, the sound field does not sound like real singing, and the overall performance is more like real singing).
Li Jian's "Wish" and "Marine": real singing.
"The Lonely Warrior" by Tengger and Bai Jugang: Doubtful.
Liu Yuxin's "63ebe9", "Rhythm Disease": real singing.
Lu Rover and Chen Zhaoxu's "The World Is Weird and Weird, But You Are So Lovely": The recording will not participate in the appraisal.
Wu Qingfeng's "The Wind Rises" and "What Are You Worrying About": Real singing.
Wu Qingfeng and Lisa Ono's "(Brown-Haired Girl)": real singing.
Lisa Ono and Wu Qingfeng's "I Do": real singing.
Hu Ge and Tang Yan's "Looking Back Again": lip-syncing.
Stars "Ode to Joy": The chorus cannot be identified.
Ayunga and Pan Hangwei's "Phantom of the Theater": real singing.
Zhang Xincheng's "Movement of the Night": real singing.
Zhao Chaofan's "Nothing Else Wanted": Real singing.
"we are musical" by Ayunga, Zhang Xincheng, Zhao Chaofan, Pan Hangwei, Miao Mengchu, Jing Yanqiao, Zhu Hanbin, Shi Yifei: Although the chorus cannot be identified, the duet chorus with higher difficulty factor is all genuine. There's no reason to lip-sync even during the chorus.
Su Xing and Wu Mochou's "Five-Star Review": Real singing.
"Mountains and Rivers" by Man Shuke, Wu Mochou, Fu Longfei and Naiwan: real singing.
Tang Jiuzhou, Cao Feiran, Zhang Wanqing "The Night Breeze Meets You": lip-syncing.
Yunfei and Gong Shuang's "China in the Lights": real singing.
ps: This identification is only for the live TV version. As for the live version and whether to replace the audio source (this possibility is extremely low), it is not within the scope of discussion.
Source｜Cover news, Minnan.com, @声学 Weibo
