Generally speaking, if a movie is released for two weeks, there is not much popularity and it is not in the scope of discussion.
However, as the box office reversal of "Me and My Motherland" on October 10 surpassed the previous "Captain of China", which won the championship for 5 consecutive days, this movie with the highest score and the most box office during the National Day became a hot topic again. topic of.
Because "My Motherland and Me" is composed of seven stories that happened in different historical periods.
was directed by four generations of directors, including Chen Kaige, Zhang Yibai, Guan Hu, Xu Zheng, Ning Hao, Xue Xiaolu, Wen Muye, etc., the post-50s, post-sixties, post-70s, and post-80s generations. Therefore, during the first film release period, seven Short film quality has become a hot topic.
The stinking sentence "There are a thousand Hamlets in the eyes of a thousand people" has become the standard for testing truth.
has no unanimous answer to "Which is the best", which truly embodies the characteristics of a hundred flowers blooming.
But in the second stage, the focus of the movie is on the well-known passages-Chen Kaige's "Day Meteor".
Someone said that "Day Meteor" was badly filmed. Originally, the director asked his son to act as the male second to drive traffic, but he didn't expect his son to be taken into the pit by his father.
also has high praises such as "Some people see meteors during the day, others can only see ghosts during the day" by the film critic Shi Hang.
No matter what, in Chinese theaters, after a movie is released, there can be such extreme polarized comments. There is really no one except Chen Kaige.
According to Shi Hang, "it is safe to laugh at poets in any era."
poet director Chen Kaige left behind the most difficult themes of "Space" and "Poverty Alleviation" after other directors first selected. The title of "Day Meteor" is full of poetry.
But since Man Jianghu Maitai's "Farewell My Concubine" was filmed by his father, Chen Kaige has indeed never filmed a work close to it in more than 20 years.
And since "The Promise", director Chen Kaige is often ridiculed by the group every time the film is released. The work is empty and ungrounded.
"Day Meteor" has almost the same reputation scene.
When mentioning "My Motherland and Me", many viewers will put "Eve", "Winning Championship" and "Hello Beijing" in the seven stories first. Although the order is slightly different, the same is that all Put "Day Meteor" at the end. What
likes will put "Day Meteor" at the forefront, but once this happens, there will often be ridicule and ridicule X on social networks, making people feel more and more reasonable for Shi Hang's statement.
Do we really understand "Day Meteor", do we misunderstand Chen Kaige?
Tucao about the chief director Chen Kaige's "Daytime Meteor" is mostly focused on ordinary people entering the return cabin casually, the plot contradictions are handled bluntly, the story is incomplete, Liu Haoran and Chen Feiyu's motivation for change is unclear, and so on.
even had a civil servant who worked in poverty alleviation at the grassroots a few years ago directly criticized the film, thinking it was an insult to poverty alleviation and poverty alleviation workers.
The cadre lists the policies that the Wardler brothers played by Liu Haoran and Chen Feiyu as the target of poverty alleviation, and the work that cadres must do to help the poor, to the retirement salary of the old banner leader and the security of the Shenzhou return cabin. A series of ridiculous and sad aspects of Director Chen's films in his eyes.
From the perspective of policy interpretation and implementation, there is nothing wrong with what he said. The poverty alleviation battle has indeed achieved initial results this year. However,
completely rejects the movie, which makes people feel unnecessary.
from the perspective of many people’s perception of the security issues of the Shenzhou return cabin. Is
a fault? I think
should be viewed from several aspects.
First of all, Chen Kaige's film solved the theme with an allegorical non-realistic film method, that is, Liu Haoran and Chen Feiyu saw the "daylight meteor", their hearts were greatly shaken, and they decided to stay in their hometown in Inner Mongolia to create the future.
Have the brothers Liu Haoran been shaken? Liu Haoran, the new Little Fresh Meat Flow King,’s acting skills really surpassed the previous generation of Little Fresh Meat, with tears on his face and dreams in his eyes. Why is
being shaken? I saw a meteor in the day.
Inner Mongolia has been deeply influenced by Shamanism since ancient times. The legends about "daylight meteors" andWhether it has anything to do with it, I don’t know, the Wardler brothers have no culture. Such people must have a profound awareness of almost worshiping legends or celestial phenomena. Once
saw a legendary celestial phenomenon, the shock to his heart was understandable.
At the same time, the old banner leader uses his life to awaken two young people who have lost their way in the world. It has a poetic and unrealistic element, but it is understandable. After all, the passing of life can completely shake some people close to him.
That Shenzhou returned to the cabin and went in so easily. Isn't it a flaw?
Some netizens found news reports that the herdsmen first discovered the return cabin when the Shenzhou 5 landed that year, proving that this situation may exist.
There are also local people from Siziwangqi who speak on the Internet and tell stories about the past of their hometown. Because when the spacecraft came down, the car was guaranteed to go on the road, and the herdsmen did not ride horses as fast as they could, so the herdsmen usually arrived first. Of course, this was the first few years. The situation of
more than a decade ago is taken as a background in 2016, is it possible?
I think if it is too true, we can even pick the bones out of the egg. Tickets for the
Olympic Games are real-named and can only be transferred once. However, Uncle Ge in "Hello, Beijing" draws the tickets, which is already a transfer, which has reached the prescribed upper limit.
gave Chuanwazi the tickets so casually, why no one said it was not in line with reality? In
, Song Jia was used as a backup fighter in "Convoy", and he did not immediately make up for the accident of his comrades plane, and decided to help his comrades on his own. This was an obvious violation of military orders.
After watching Li Yunlong, the audience thought that it was natural for the thorns in the army to operate like this. They did not realize that "obeying orders" was the first duty of soldiers, and there was absolutely zero tolerance for disobedience in the army. of.
Isn't this a fault?
In "Win the Championship", everyone watched the women's volleyball team win the championship in the Shanghai alley. There were also problems. The 1984 Mid-Autumn Women's Volleyball battle was played at 8pm in Los Angeles, USA, and at 6am in China. But it was noon in the movie, why no one said this? Is
just a reasonable plot?
As for the anger of poverty alleviation cadres, it is understandable from his perspective. But as far as the movie is concerned, it can only be said that he has looked at the problem one-sidedly with wishful thinking.
The poverty alleviation work is indeed carefully arranged, but there are also acts of dereliction of duty, dereliction of duty and violation of discipline.
again, and some netizens on the Internet issued an article "Tit-for-tat": The national targeted poverty alleviation work is already in place to some extent. Schools in many poverty-stricken areas have now greatly improved their hardware, and material assistance from all walks of life is also coming. Continuously. But relative to their material abundance, their spiritual world is still barren, and cultural poverty alleviation is still seriously lacking.
Therefore, the old banner leader in the film knew that the two bad boys could not be saved materially, so he had to work hard, so he took the little brothers to ride to the "day meteor" far beyond their recognition. In the movie
, the smoke and dust scene brought up by the three masters while riding a horse on the Gobi. The combination of the distant view and the light and shadow is the best representation of Chen Kaige’s poetry, just like the phrase "Silver Saddle Illuminates White Horse" in Li Bai's "Xia Ke Xing" , Rustling like a meteor". The lens of
is the most impactful to the audience's vision, it is definitely not limited to beauty.
Don't believe in miracles.
Siziwangqi, I have been reading "Four Princes" for more than 20 years. He is the fifteenth-generation grandson of Genghis Khan’s brother Ha. He has four sons who live in separate pastures, so it is called the four-child tribe, and the title of the four-child king banner comes from this.
More than ten years ago, there was no such thing as a city. There was only one main street in the urban area, not even a county seat.
However, since the Shenzhou spacecraft landed here more than ten years ago, Siziwangqi has undergone earth-shaking changes, gradually turning from the wild outside the Great Wall into a well-known aerospace attraction, and the local poverty situation has gradually improved.
More importantly, like the Wardler brothers in the film, the countless Siziwangqi children who were shocked by the "day meteors" have become space fans. It is hard to say what kind of development there will be in the future.
Even if you do not become a scientific researcher, it is not a bad thing to have a richer spiritual world as an ordinary person.
Therefore, the combination of poverty alleviation and the aerospace industry is not a matter of rigid and random patchwork among certain populations.
whileIn the interview, Chen Kaige also explained in detail why he would integrate poverty alleviation and aviation.
He emphasized that "spiritual poverty alleviation" must be more important than "material poverty alleviation".
Therefore, in the movie, Tian Zhuangzhuang's Lao Qichang said to Chen Feiyu, who is supporting the little lamb, "How long can you help it stand?" This is the core of the movie.
and let the two brothers stand on their own, the film took advantage of the legend of the "daylight meteor" on the grassland, and the return of the Shenzhou spacecraft served as a miracle that led them to stand up.
Shi Hang said on Weibo, (you just laugh at Chen Kaige) might miss the understanding in looking up.
Of course, Chen Kaige's part is indeed quite different from the previous ones in style. Perhaps the limitation of space also makes it difficult for many people to understand. But if this short film is expanded into a longer one, I am also worried about whether Director Chen's state can be maintained.
are just those who laugh at Chen Kaige's "Day Meteor", and always make me feel that they are a group of people who laugh at Faye Wong's "Me and My Motherland" theme song of the same name.
They don't accept diversity, they prefer one voice.
I think the worst thing Chen Kaige did is on the poster.
Obviously, Wu Jing and Ma Yili do not have a two-minute play, but the protagonist, Han Haolin, did not even show up.
For the sake of the box office, I can only say that Chen Kaige is vulgar now, this is really not misunderstood.
