"A Dream of Red Mansions" directed by Hu Mei only sold 4.6 million at the box office six days after its release. This movie, which took 18 years and attracted widespread attention during the casting process, has now become "summer cannon fodder", which is ironic enough.
Audiences have many dissatisfaction with the movie, among which the appearance of "Lin Daiyu" has become the focus of heated discussion among netizens. Especially during the movie road show, the actor Zhang Miaoyi who played "Lin Daiyu" called "Lin Daiyu" a mean and deviant person, which made "book fans" and "drama fans" angry.
Some people think that even if Zhang Miaoyi had read the original work, she would not have said such words, adding another person to the "desperate illiterates" in domestic entertainment.
Some people think that Zhang Miaoyi's appearance and temperament are not suitable for the role of "Lin Daiyu" at all, saying that she has no self-awareness.
In fact, considering that she was only 19 years old when the movie was filmed, Zhang Miaoyi's performance was quite satisfactory, and she even had a bit of spirituality in it.
The reason why many netizens criticize Zhang Miaoyi for her poor appearance may be caused by a picture posted by a netizen (picture below).
Some netizens said that the new version of "Lin Daiyu" has the image of " small eyes, big nose, thick mouth and rabbit front teeth "?
Zhang Miaoyi looks like this, even people who have never watched "Dream of Red Mansions" think that this is not "Lin Daiyu". But it is a bit arbitrary to judge Zhang Miaoyi's poor image based on just one movie screenshot.
Director Hu Mei also expressed considerable dissatisfaction with the circulation of this picture, saying that this picture was a photoshopped picture and that the publisher should be held accountable. It is still unclear whether
is a fake picture, and director Hu Mei’s one-sided words cannot convince the public.
In fact, Zhang Miaoyi's performance in the movie is passable most of the time, both in terms of appearance and acting skills. After all, when thousands of people participated in the role audition, Zhang Miaoyi was able to stay, which shows that there is something special about her.
In reality, Zhang Miaoyi's appearance is not outstanding in domestic entertainment, but it is not "ugly" either.
The reason why the audience is so picky about the so-called "deep love and deep responsibility" is because "Dream of Red Mansions" is too classic.
Not to mention the original work, the "87 drama version of Dream of Red Mansions" alone has already shaped the image of Lin Daiyu. Many viewers believe that Chen Xiaoxu is Lin Daiyu herself.
Even Tao Huimin, the "great beauty" at the time, encountered a lot of controversy when she played Lin Daiyu in the "89 film version of Dream of Red Mansions".
However, Zhang Miaoyi is not as good as Chen Xiaoxu in temperament, and cannot compare with Tao Huimin in appearance. It is very normal for the audience to question her.
recognizes his own shortcomings and faces the problems sincerely.
But today’s actors, for the sake of traffic, just want to make things big.
After being questioned, Zhang Miaoyi wrote a lot of words on her own account to respond to the audience's doubts.
Because there are a lot of words, here is a summary of Zhang Miaoyi’s views.
1. I am sad to see the criticism on the Internet, but I do not regret playing "Lin Daiyu".
2. Everyone called me ugly, ignorant, and superficial, but I was selected from an audition team of thousands of people. I stayed on the crew for nearly a year. Not only did I undergo professional training, I also read the original works and script.
3. He started praising director Hu Mei. The only one who felt sorry for her was Hu Mei.
This response is really difficult to comment on.
seems to be an apology, but in fact it is full of confusing logic, but it is also full of "human feelings and sophistication", showing the characteristics of the entertainment industry at a glance.
Zhang Miaoyi said that she was fearless because of her ignorance, but the conversation changed to "I survived a talent competition with thousands of people." After "8 months of preparation and 100 days of shooting..."
This is obviously not "looking for cause and effect", this is telling about hard work.Even if I don’t have any merit, I still have hard work. Even if you are tired, it is still a kind of sacrifice, right?
In fact, netizens felt that Zhang Miaoyi 's interpretation of the character "Lin Daiyu" was problematic and deviated from the original work. However, Zhang Miaoyi did not provide any explanation for this in her response. She just expressed the attitude of "you can scold me, I don't care."
What’s even more surprising is that Zhang Miaoyi said that the person she felt most sorry for was director Hu Mei.
Some netizens directly pointed out that it was not the director whom Zhang Miaoyi was sorry for, but Dream of Red Mansions, Lin Daiyu and the audience. Moreover, director Hu Mei also failed the original work and the audience.
Some netizens ridiculed: It was obviously the characters and the audience who were sorry, but in the end, Zhang Miaoyi apologized to the director, and then forgave herself. Not only does he not understand Lin Daiyu, but he also doesn’t understand Zhu Bajie, and he also likes to break defenses.
At the end of the response, Zhang Miaoyi wrote this -
I think that "A Dream of Red Mansions: A Beautiful Marriage" has caused huge controversy and attracted huge attention. If more people buy the original book and read it, go find it. Judging from the classic works, this is also a good thing for the popularization of Chinese classics.
This passage is even more speechless.
Who is taking advantage of whom in the movie "A Dream of Red Mansions" and the original book "A Dream of Red Mansions"? Without the banner of "Dream of Red Mansions", the movie character auditions could make such a big splash. Without the banner of "Dream of Red Mansions", the box office might not exceed 4 million.
What's more, the filming of "A Dream of Red Mansions: A Dream of Red Mansions" was not very good. According to normal logic, after watching such a movie version of Dream of Red Mansions, those viewers who have not read the original work will have no interest in understanding where it came from. "More people will buy the original work and read it"?
The reason why "Dream of Red Mansions" is called a masterpiece is because it is relatively popular. The story of "Dream of Red Mansions" is included in primary school textbooks, and it is also part of the middle school exam. Zhang Miaoyi doesn't even know these things. Is it really a "nine-leak fish"?
Only good entertainment products can be said to be "promoting and popularizing". For example, the domestic 3A game "Black Myth Wukong" released recently has driven Shanxi's cultural tourism industry and promoted Chinese traditional culture to the world.
"Dream of Red Mansions: The Golden Marriage" has become like this, and it even claims to "drive the popularization of "Dream of Red Mansions" again." Where does the confidence come from?
Great domestic entertainment directors, stop tossing around the four classics. The film and television production of "Dream of Red Mansions" is really not as simple as "renting a big house, finding some young and beautiful actors, and making it a box office hit."
"A Dream of Red Mansions" directed by Hu Mei only sold 4.6 million at the box office six days after its release. This movie, which took 18 years and attracted widespread attention during the casting process, has now become "summer cannon fodder", which is ironic enough.
Audiences have many dissatisfaction with the movie, among which the appearance of "Lin Daiyu" has become the focus of heated discussion among netizens. Especially during the movie road show, the actor Zhang Miaoyi who played "Lin Daiyu" called "Lin Daiyu" a mean and deviant person, which made "book fans" and "drama fans" angry.
Some people think that even if Zhang Miaoyi had read the original work, she would not have said such words, adding another person to the "desperate illiterates" in domestic entertainment.
Some people think that Zhang Miaoyi's appearance and temperament are not suitable for the role of "Lin Daiyu" at all, saying that she has no self-awareness.
In fact, considering that she was only 19 years old when the movie was filmed, Zhang Miaoyi's performance was quite satisfactory, and she even had a bit of spirituality in it.
The reason why many netizens criticize Zhang Miaoyi for her poor appearance may be caused by a picture posted by a netizen (picture below).
Some netizens said that the new version of "Lin Daiyu" has the image of " small eyes, big nose, thick mouth and rabbit front teeth "?
Zhang Miaoyi looks like this, even people who have never watched "Dream of Red Mansions" think that this is not "Lin Daiyu". But it is a bit arbitrary to judge Zhang Miaoyi's poor image based on just one movie screenshot.
Director Hu Mei also expressed considerable dissatisfaction with the circulation of this picture, saying that this picture was a photoshopped picture and that the publisher should be held accountable. It is still unclear whether
is a fake picture, and director Hu Mei’s one-sided words cannot convince the public.
In fact, Zhang Miaoyi's performance in the movie is passable most of the time, both in terms of appearance and acting skills. After all, when thousands of people participated in the role audition, Zhang Miaoyi was able to stay, which shows that there is something special about her.
In reality, Zhang Miaoyi's appearance is not outstanding in domestic entertainment, but it is not "ugly" either.
The reason why the audience is so picky about the so-called "deep love and deep responsibility" is because "Dream of Red Mansions" is too classic.
Not to mention the original work, the "87 drama version of Dream of Red Mansions" alone has already shaped the image of Lin Daiyu. Many viewers believe that Chen Xiaoxu is Lin Daiyu herself.
Even Tao Huimin, the "great beauty" at the time, encountered a lot of controversy when she played Lin Daiyu in the "89 film version of Dream of Red Mansions".
However, Zhang Miaoyi is not as good as Chen Xiaoxu in temperament, and cannot compare with Tao Huimin in appearance. It is very normal for the audience to question her.
recognizes his own shortcomings and faces the problems sincerely.
But today’s actors, for the sake of traffic, just want to make things big.
After being questioned, Zhang Miaoyi wrote a lot of words on her own account to respond to the audience's doubts.
Because there are a lot of words, here is a summary of Zhang Miaoyi’s views.
1. I am sad to see the criticism on the Internet, but I do not regret playing "Lin Daiyu".
2. Everyone called me ugly, ignorant, and superficial, but I was selected from an audition team of thousands of people. I stayed on the crew for nearly a year. Not only did I undergo professional training, I also read the original works and script.
3. He started praising director Hu Mei. The only one who felt sorry for her was Hu Mei.
This response is really difficult to comment on.
seems to be an apology, but in fact it is full of confusing logic, but it is also full of "human feelings and sophistication", showing the characteristics of the entertainment industry at a glance.
Zhang Miaoyi said that she was fearless because of her ignorance, but the conversation changed to "I survived a talent competition with thousands of people." After "8 months of preparation and 100 days of shooting..."
This is obviously not "looking for cause and effect", this is telling about hard work.Even if I don’t have any merit, I still have hard work. Even if you are tired, it is still a kind of sacrifice, right?
In fact, netizens felt that Zhang Miaoyi 's interpretation of the character "Lin Daiyu" was problematic and deviated from the original work. However, Zhang Miaoyi did not provide any explanation for this in her response. She just expressed the attitude of "you can scold me, I don't care."
What’s even more surprising is that Zhang Miaoyi said that the person she felt most sorry for was director Hu Mei.
Some netizens directly pointed out that it was not the director whom Zhang Miaoyi was sorry for, but Dream of Red Mansions, Lin Daiyu and the audience. Moreover, director Hu Mei also failed the original work and the audience.
Some netizens ridiculed: It was obviously the characters and the audience who were sorry, but in the end, Zhang Miaoyi apologized to the director, and then forgave herself. Not only does he not understand Lin Daiyu, but he also doesn’t understand Zhu Bajie, and he also likes to break defenses.
At the end of the response, Zhang Miaoyi wrote this -
I think that "A Dream of Red Mansions: A Beautiful Marriage" has caused huge controversy and attracted huge attention. If more people buy the original book and read it, go find it. Judging from the classic works, this is also a good thing for the popularization of Chinese classics.
This passage is even more speechless.
Who is taking advantage of whom in the movie "A Dream of Red Mansions" and the original book "A Dream of Red Mansions"? Without the banner of "Dream of Red Mansions", the movie character auditions could make such a big splash. Without the banner of "Dream of Red Mansions", the box office might not exceed 4 million.
What's more, the filming of "A Dream of Red Mansions: A Dream of Red Mansions" was not very good. According to normal logic, after watching such a movie version of Dream of Red Mansions, those viewers who have not read the original work will have no interest in understanding where it came from. "More people will buy the original work and read it"?
The reason why "Dream of Red Mansions" is called a masterpiece is because it is relatively popular. The story of "Dream of Red Mansions" is included in primary school textbooks, and it is also part of the middle school exam. Zhang Miaoyi doesn't even know these things. Is it really a "nine-leak fish"?
Only good entertainment products can be said to be "promoting and popularizing". For example, the domestic 3A game "Black Myth Wukong" released recently has driven Shanxi's cultural tourism industry and promoted Chinese traditional culture to the world.
"Dream of Red Mansions: The Golden Marriage" has become like this, and it even claims to "drive the popularization of "Dream of Red Mansions" again." Where does the confidence come from?
Great domestic entertainment directors, stop tossing around the four classics. The film and television production of "Dream of Red Mansions" is really not as simple as "renting a big house, finding some young and beautiful actors, and making it a box office hit."
Dear friends, what do you think? Welcome to leave a message and discuss together!
——end——
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-