"Above the Cliff" directed by Zhang Yimou, is this spy war movie worth watching?

Foreword: I haven't seen this movie before, and I watched it with a high rating on the Internet and it is a movie directed by Zhang Yimou and , so I came to see it. I like movies with logical plots and characters. This article mainly analyzes this movie from a logical perspective.

Movie type: Plot / Action / Suspense Northeast China, Japanese-occupied Puppet Manchukuo, Harbin, Winter "'s covert operation.

Plot analysis:

1. With such an important task as "Utla", the organization will actually send a couple and a couple to perform the task, and they have to be forcibly separated, so there can be no movie without love.

2. Under the circumstance that the spy has an absolute advantage, why only tie Zhang Xianchen alone and leave Zhang Lan still in the dark? Can't you just tie both of them? They had to give them a chance to fight back, and the spy Lao Feng's response was too slow. He had time to shoot before Zhang Xianchen killed another spy.

3. There are so many people in the whole carriage of the train, why did the spy have to go directly to search Zhang Lan? Can you give a reasonable explanation? Is this a forcible conflict? Maybe he was out of professional vigilance, but he gave Zhang Xianchen a chance to save people. Is there a spy in this car? This is a bit far-fetched. If there are two more people, can he save them?

4. Zhang Lan forcibly killed the spy at the train station. Why didn't he see it so powerful before? Anyway, he has been fighting back since the beginning of the movie. It's different if you have the aura of the protagonist. All killed, a bit of a cool feeling. It's strange that the sound of the shots didn't attract the other agents who were searching. The agents were really blind and deaf.

5. There is no camouflage in the codebook that Wang Yu brought, so people can see at a glance, is this an agent? "It's a razor, in fact it's a hair dryer", the agents in the star movie are the real agents, at least with a cover up.

6. Zhang Xianchen dressed up as a woman and went to the bookstore to pick up books, but the spy didn't know him, so why did he keep chasing him after he came out? As a well-trained spy on the mission, he got out of the car to look for the child under the enemy's pursuit. This is really bullshit. When escaping the alley, I kept looking to the right, but if I looked to the left, I would not be hit by a car. There was no way. The director wanted him to pick up the lunch, and the detailed address of Zhang Lan could be asked from the driver. As an old man Did the agent tell the driver the address directly without any sense of anti-investigation? Shouldn't there be a detour or a few transfers? The spy agents went into Zhang Lan's room and waited for the rabbits, and no one was watching outside. The spy agents' professional level was really amateurish, and the plot was really mentally retarded.

7. After being rescued in prison, Zhang Xianchen doesn't need to escape, so why not commit suicide? Back then, everyone came here with the determination to die. This may be to show that the spies are not useless or have a role.

8. After the car chase scene, the two of them fought against a number of spies and won. There is a sense of sight of the two eagles here. Card blocking or something? to here forStop, I have never seen a Japanese appear. You must know that the Northeast at that time was the world of the Japanese. As soon as military police or something came out, which agent could drive a car to escape. It's ridiculous to have a historical background but be out of the historical background.

9. The movie always emphasizes the "Utra" action, but the ending is very hasty, and the task is directly brought out. There is nothing in the process. .

don't talk about the acting skills of the actors, everyone has their favorite actors, and they don't talk about the quality of the special effects. After all, you may not like the scenes I like. This article only analyzes the logic of the plot. Row away.

movie recommendation index: three stars, friends who like it can watch it.