He also plays Bao Qingtian. Comparing the versions of Zhou Jie, Deng Chao and Jin Chaoqun, the gap comes out.


" Kaifeng has a Bao Qingtian , who is unselfish and discriminating between loyal and traitors..."


This song is almost known to everyone, and Bao Qingtian's story is not known to everyone. He is not only a real character in history, but also a character who has been put on the screen countless times.


From 1993 Jin Chaoqun version of "Bao Qingtian", to Zhou Jie 's "Youth Bao Qingtian", and then to Deng Chao 's "Juvenile Bao Qingtian: The Legend of Tianmang", it can be said that each has its own characteristics. .


Jin Chaoqun, who has a wide body and a black face, has performed 236 episodes in a row, which is an insurmountable classic; Zhou Jie, who is calm and youthful, is the most popular with the audience, but Deng Chao's version is too "crazy", which has attracted the whole network to complain.


Although they all play Bao Qingtian, but comparing the three of them, the difference comes out immediately...



01, Jin Chaoqun


Jin Chaoqun, who graduated from the film and drama department, began to participate in stage plays at the age of 18. Assistant director, but there is no fire. When


signed a contract with a TV company, he suffered a loss because of his looks, and became a special trooper, and he continued to struggle at the bottom until he was 42 years old.


At that time, Jin Chaoqun fell in love with Chen Qi, who was in love in "Prodigy". In order to let his lover have a good life, he opened a teahouse, and in the third year he owed more than 4 million in debt.


At this time, Jin Chaoqun, who ran back to the crew to make money and pay off his debts, met TVB who wanted to film "Bao Qingtian".


Before the filming of this drama, TVB also found a lot of people, but because there are senior Zhuyu in various fields ahead, there are very few people who dare to challenge. The signboard, so no one dared to try it.


until director Sun Shupei found Jin Chaoqun.


"You have been from elementary school Peking Opera , you only need to gain some fat to fit the image of Bao Gong ." You can't live without it.


So 42-year-old Jin Chaoqun started to use various high-fat foods to gain weight in order to meet the director's requirements. In the end, his body became as wide as a balloon, and the flesh on his face was too much to be seen. .


arrived in the crew, used coffee powder to do a drill and painted it on his face, and then matched it with a Peking Opera robe. Before the director opened his mouth, people around him began to praise him.


"This is Bao Zheng!" The reason why this version of "Bao Qingtian"


has become a classic is that, in addition to Jin Chaoqun's resemblance to his appearance, he also tried to make himself more like a majestic and powerful official. Practice in front of a mirror.


Jin Chaoqun spends more than 10 hours shooting under the camera every day. In order not to affect his makeup and clothes, he does not dare to move even when he is resting, and he does not even drink water unless he can.


, which was originally planned to have only 15 episodes, has just aired 2 episodes, and it has created a splendid scene. In the


drama, Jin Chaoqun has a profound sense of righteousness, is not afraid of power, can communicate with both the yin and yang, and his upright image has firmly caught everyone's attention, so that the popularity of the show even defeated the then-viewing champion "One". The Royal Court".


has this momentum, and the investors continued to shoot back, and a full 236 episodes were filmed.


Jin Chaoqun, who once "checked no such person", also became a "national idol" overnight.



Two years later, Jin Chaoqun won the Golden Bell Award for Best Actor for this drama, but it's a pity that the fat he gained because of the needs of the drama can no longer be reduced. After


, he also tried to play other roles, but no matter how he played, he couldn't get rid of Bao Zheng's shadow. So from 2000, Jin Chaoqun simply announced that he would no longer play any roles other than Bao Qingtian.


"I'm going to keep playing this role until I can't play it, until the audience no longer needs it."


Jin Chaoqun not only put in all his savings to prepare for the filming of "Bao Qingtian", but also directly built a " Super Studios ".



is not for sightseeing, not for business, it is specially used to shoot Bao Qingtian.


" Bao Gong's Tour ", " Bao Qingtian: The Kaifeng Case ", "Five Mice Fighting the Royal Cat"... and other dramas have all been filmed in his film and television city.


Jin Chaoqun's heart of Bao Gong's verdict is justice, a tug of war between good and evil, and a very high sense of loyalty and filial piety hidden under the guise of the verdict.


In his eyes, Bao Qingtian is no longer a story, but a Chinese culture worth spreading.


"I only want to play such a role in my life."


Jin Chaoqun did it. He made Bao Zheng in the book live in reality, and he also left a classic image to the world!



02, Zhou Jie


Compared with Jin Chaoqun's dignified and dignified, Zhou Jie's young Bao Zheng is much younger.


In 1999, "Youth Bao Qingtian" just started to plan and shoot, the first thought was to invite the popular Wu Qilong to play Bao Zheng.


As a result, the other party was afraid that the black-faced Bao Gong would ruin his idol image, so he refused directly. The producer of


found Zhou Jie, who was on the fire of " Huanzhugege " at that time. With the previous experience, the producer also specially advised Zhou Jie.


"If you are afraid of being ugly and don't want to play Bao Zheng, you can also try Gongsun Ce." Erkang ", Zhou Jie, who was hesitant, had to make a phone call to Qiong Yao.


As a result, Qiong Yao became popular as soon as she heard it.


"It's hard to create the image of Erkang now, and suddenly you want to become a black face. You have to bear the consequences."


Although everyone around him disagreed with him, Zhou Jie still felt that such a good script was too good not to act. Pity.


thought about it, but still didn't listen to Qiong Yao's opinion. After


joined the crew, the makeup artist wanted to use shoe polish directly on the "black face" makeup, but was directly rejected by Zhou Jie.


"Let's use the darkest foundation."


Finally, Zhou Jie's version of Bao Qingtian has become recognized as a "childhood", with a reasonable plot, ups and downs of suspense, and interlocking conspiracies.


The young Zhou Jie has just managed the blood of the young Bao Zheng just right, and the young man has become a breeze in the turbid officialdom.


He showed the intelligence, simplicity and justice of the young Bao Qingtian to the fullest. The audience can clearly see him from the initial intelligence to the later calm, and can see the process of Bao Qingtian's growth.


In the whole drama, Zhou Jie's acting skills can be released and controlled. He is serious when he is serious and in love when he is leisure, and he has an excellent sense of proportion.


Zhou Jie's performance made this drama a classic in the hearts of countless people.



It's a pity that there are many popular people. When Zhou Jie left after filming the first part, all kinds of speculation and rumors dragged him down from the altar.


Someone said that when Zhou Jie and Li Bingbing were filming a big game in the winter, Li Bingbing had to soak in cold water for a long time.


Zhou Jie just shook his head helplessly when he heard this. "She and I have never filmed a scene in the water at all."


Some people also said that he originally signed three "Youth Bao Qingtian", but when the first film was a big hit, he and the producer left because they couldn't agree on the payment. .


In fact, Zhou Jie did sign a contract to shoot three films at the beginning, but in the end he didn't do it, but it was not because the money was too little, but because the quality of the script did not meet Zhou Jie's requirements, he really couldn't convince himself to do it. .


"After I read the script, I felt that it was too far from my expectations, so I didn't want to act." After


, Zhou Jie appeared less and less on the screen, which made many people suspect that he was too difficult to hire . There was also a reporter who specifically asked him this question, but Zhou Jie felt that there was nothing to avoid and answered very directly.


"Because I'm too picky, sometimes I really think why the script is written like this? It's a complete waste." ”, he put his energy on investment and collection.


Later, he unexpectedly went to plant rice, and even donated millions of rice for relief during the epidemic.


Although we haven't seen his "Bao Zheng" again, in reality, he is still the principled and kind Zhou Jie.



03, Deng Chao


Compared with Zhou Jie's high requirements for the script, Deng Chao seems a little more casual. When


arrived in "The Legend of Young Bao Qingtian: Tianmang Legend", the elements of solving cases in the whole drama were greatly reduced, and the opposite emotional scenes were increased a lot.


Let's not talk about Deng Chao's acting skills, just the flaws in the plot make people not fall in love with this drama.


Bao Zheng, who was originally wise and wise, got the amnesia script at the beginning, but a person's amnesia is not a change of brain, and it will not change his personality.


Although the original Jay Chou's Bao Qingtian personality is a bit out of place at some point, he will never become a "fool who eats a dozen buns at a meal"”, not to mention that there are too many clues that have nothing to do with the case in the process of solving the case.


In addition to the flaws in the plot, Deng Chao’s acting skills are also really unsatisfactory. This drama seems to be a dividing line. Before it,


, Deng Chao is the melancholy and lonely "Juvenile Shunzhi Emperor " in " Young Emperor ". After that, Deng Chao became a funny and crazy "Super Brother".



At the beginning of the filming of this drama, the investors did not choose the circle It is not difficult to see the innovation behind this move.


Even Deng Chao has publicly commented on the difference between him and Zhou Jie's Bao Zheng Yes.


"Bao Zheng in the front is all shrewd and capable, I am smart and capable, cute and silly, making the characters more plump. "


He also said that the way the plot is arranged is to make the audience feel funny, but it is by no means boring, but the final effect is really unsightly. Lived the original brilliant detective line, which made people eat like wax.


abruptly turned a drama into a romantic comedy, which made the audience who like "Youth Bao Qingtian" couldn't help but sigh. It's a pity.


producer Chen Yong also said that if the plot is too exaggerated or the actors do not grasp it well, it will be self-defeating. His original intention was to get rid of the audience's aesthetic fatigue, but he fluttered, causing the whole network to complain. Deng Chao has become a "fool" in the people's mouths.


Although Deng Chao's acting skills are not as good as Zhou Jie's, his development has really left Zhou Jie dozens of streets.



Bao Qingtian went online in the second year, Deng Chao turned to the film circle with Zhao Erdou in " Assembly No. " , and directly won the Best Supporting Actor in the Hundred Flowers Awards .


followed a "Di Renjie: The Empire of Heaven", which won him the Academy Award nomination, and the commercial film " China Partner " won the Good box office.


" scorching sun "'s acting skills exploded, making people fascinated by his peak acting skills, this film also won him the Golden Rooster Award .


In 2014, Deng Chao appeared on the national variety show " run, brother ", the popularity has skyrocketed.


took the name and made a lot of money Deng Chao was not idle at all, and immediately entered the director's world. Although a " breakup master " has a low reputation, it has also gained a good reputation Box office.


A "Shadow" shut up everyone who said he was a "variety artist" and a "bad movie king".


plus his "love" like Sun Li, Deng Chao has always been in the circle The first line of the film, the word 'passed' seems to have never appeared in him.



04, the epilogue


are also three people who play Bao Qingtian. Jin Chaoqun has never been able to go out in his life. Time and effort left a classic in the world.


Zhou Jie used Bao Qingtian to remove the label of "white-faced scholar" from himself. Unfortunately, his character is not suitable for surviving in this circle. It is a good choice to leave here and go to a place where he is better at.


On the other hand, Deng Chao, who has the worst acting skills among all Bao Qingtians, although there are some childish scenes in the play, he has countless connections outside the play, endless movies, and the strongest backing. No matter how many bad movies he makes,


Someone will pay for him, it is hard to say that it is not another ability.


People may feel proud and disappointed for a moment, but no one knows what will happen tomorrow; today's fire may disappear tomorrow, and the current trough may reach its peak in the future.


No matter the situation at this time, as long as there is light in your heart, you will definitely find your own path.


-END-

【文 | 苏达

【责编 | 语非年 】

关注@柴叔带你看电影更多精彩不迷路!