Why does the academic community support Guo Songmin's criticism of the film "Hidden in the Dust"?

has long insisted on criticizing Hu Xijin Mr. Guo Songmin . Recently, he has been smoking for three days to comment on the movie " Hidden in the Dust ".

Then, a group of people on the Internet began to break their hearts, thinking that Guo Songmin was the second of Sima Nan , and he was attacking China's good movies.

So what plumber Shen Yu wants to ask is, is Guo Songmin's criticism of "Hidden in the Dust" the same as Sima Nan's malicious criticism of Mo Yan ?

Let's start with Sima Nan's criticism of Mo Yan. When Comrade Mo Yan won the Nobel Prize for Literature in 2016, what was Sima Nan's attitude? At that time, the whole people praised Mo Yan, and as long as Mo Yan was praised, the articles had huge traffic.

Since then, Sima Nan has long written and praised Mo Yan. By 2020, due to the criticism of some well-known literati in China, the social sentiment has gradually turned into populism. Mo Yan's novels objectively recorded the lives of the masses during the three-year difficult period, and were considered by the populist group as a smear of the country, and then Mo Yan's novels were regarded as a smear of the country. Mr. Mo Yan's Nobel Prize for Literature is said to be what Westerners love to hear in order to please Westerners.

This sentiment was quickly polarized by some people at the bottom who had simple patriotic thoughts but lacked cognitive ability, but any article criticizing Mo Yan could gain huge traffic.

So, this business opportunity was captured by Sima Nan. He started multiple videos in a row, using the kind of argument that is completely inciting emotions and stimulating emotions, to achieve his personal purpose of harvesting traffic.

That is to say, for a person's evaluation, whether it is praise or criticism, Sima Nan's starting point is to see if there is traffic. He doesn't care where the literary and artist's creative starting point is, whether it conforms to the truth of history.

Mo Yan's novels have transformed history into life, attached to each flesh and blood, and faithfully reproduced the hardships the Chinese have experienced to people today and in the future. As a writer, he has fulfilled his responsibility.

Then let's take a look at the movie "Hidden in the Dust".

Suffering for the sake of suffering, and pretending to be ugly for the sake of being ugly, what was the original propaganda point of the film? It is Haiqing 's daring to break through, almost disfigured appearance. Over time, the plight of farmers became a selling point. At least half of the people who are active on this online platform today are in rural areas, and at least more than a quarter of their friends go back to the countryside every Spring Festival, right? I would like to ask everyone, is your hometown still like the countryside in the movie "Hidden in the Dust"? Are there families like Haiqing in your village? Are there still women in your village in this state of the character played by Hai Qing? What about ten years ago? Even twenty years ago?

is a movie, it tells about the countryside, at least it must be in line with the historical reality. China's 40 years of reform and opening up, and 20 years of new rural construction, is it really fruitless as described in the film?

Guo Songmin is based on the grand view of history and human nature, and examines the current bad atmosphere in the field of Chinese film and television. With the rationality of a scholar, he stood up and said a few fair words on behalf of the people, and he was classified as a person like Sima Nan. How unfair this is!

is now making rumors that "Hidden in the Dust" has been taken off the shelves by capital, is that so? Yesterday I also saw a click button on a platform where you can pay to watch. I watched

, but I regret it, I shouldn't support this kind of lie that is completely for hype.

would like to thank Guo Songmin for such upright thinkers and observers. For "Hidden Into the Dust", a lie that comprehensively denies the great achievements of the country's reform and opening up, should be severely criticized and heard.

won an international film award for the perspective of Hai Qing and others who wish to play ugly to please Westerners to observe Chinese people. This phenomenon is the reality of Chinese literary and art circles. As long as you are a conscientious Chinese, you should resolve the opposition!