2019 has passed, but many friends still remember the "Wandering Earth" at the beginning of the year. This movie has won an excellent box office and an overwhelming reputation as soon as it appeared. It not only won more than 4.6 billion box office, The Douban score finally stabilized at 7.9. It can be said that before "Wandering Earth", no domestic science fiction film has achieved such a good result
. Therefore, at that time, some people even defined 2019 as the first year of Chinese science fiction movies, but it was similar. Correspondingly, there are quite a few people on the Internet who sneered at this movie. Even so far, the most popular film review on "Wandering Earth" on Douban is still a one-star bad review. So what about this movie?
In the movie, the Earth needs to use Jupiter to complete a gravitational slingshot, so it must be close to Jupiter. In the process of approaching Jupiter, due to insufficient estimates of Jupiter's gravitational influence, there has been a large-scale shutdown of planetary engines, so the effect of inertia The lower earth is getting closer and closer to Jupiter, even breaking through the Roche limit of the fluid, approaching the Roche limit of the rigid body. As a result, the earth is facing a crisis of understanding the body. In fact, I think from these points of view "Wandering Earth" can already belong The category of hard-core sci-fi movies is
. After all, compared to some sci-fi movies that sell special effects, it does involve a lot of real astrophysics concepts, but at the same time, there are indeed some scientific flaws in the wandering earth. The most widely criticized is that the Roche limit between the ground and the wood is wrong. Someone has calculated that the fluid Roche limit between the earth and Jupiter is about 105,000 kilometers, and the rigid Roche limit is about 55,000 kilometers. The closest distance to Jupiter is about 70,000 kilometers, which seems to be no problem, but the Roche limit refers to the distance between the centers of two celestial bodies
and the 70,000 kilometers given in the movie is the distance from the surface of the Earth to the surface of Jupiter. The radius of Jupiter is as long as 70,000 kilometers, the radius of the earth is more than 6,000 kilometers. That is to say, the earth’s atmosphere can only be captured if the distance between the wood surface is less than 30,000 kilometers. If the distance in the movie is true, the earth should still be safe, but it needs It means that after all, this is a movie, not a science and education film. Without affecting the plot, some subtle flaws in the scientific setting are not indicative of fatal problems. After all, there are no so-called so-called science fiction films. It’s a “hard injury”
. I believe many people know that this movie is adapted from Liu Cixin’s novel of the same name, but it’s not so much a modification as a brand new creation based on the original setting. There are about 30,000 novels in "The Wandering Earth" The characters involved in the movie content are only about a thousand words. One can imagine how huge the expanded content is. In fact, the intersection of ground and wood shown in the movie is not an important plot in the original work, including the crisis of ground and wood collision. They are all innovative content based on the original work
. So after the movie came out, some of the original works were not bought. After all, what the original works express is really very different from the movies, except for a large number of original plots that are not shown in the film. In addition, there are some differences in the humanistic thinking of the two. For example, in the original book, when the earth is in a huge crisis, the feelings between people are relatively weak, while the feelings between people in the movie It’s obviously a lot more
. If the original show shows the extremely low calmness of human beings under the catastrophe, then the movie shows the unselfish love of human beings under the catastrophe. The original works in the movie are indeed quite different in many aspects. It’s big, but I can really say which one is better, because it depends on personal taste. Although the movie is just a short paragraph adapted from the original, the two-hour content can be described as quite detailed. The plot is wave after wave. First introduce the background of the story through Liu Qizhi, and then start The machine was shut down, and then everyone rescued Hangzhou, Sulawesi, and finally ignited Jupiter to save the earth
. The content is very compact. It can be said that there is almost no redundant plot in two hours, but this is both an advantage and a disadvantage. The world view of "Earth" is already huge, and the amount of information in the movie is huge per minute. The content of two or even three movies that could have been made is compressed in one movie, which will inevitably make some audiences unable to keep up. The rhythm of the plot, not to mention, the 125-minute version we have seen is still a cut version. It is said that the original version is nearly half an hour longer than this, which is why some plots in the movie are more jumpy
. There is no denying that this movie does not. Too much budget is spent on star salaries, the biggest star Wu Jing not only didn’t wantI also paid for the movie and invested 60 million in the movie, but I don’t know why, but many people can’t accept Wu Jing. Some people even call this movie "Space Wolf Warrior" because of Wu Jing’s appearance. Besides, I don’t think of the actors in the movie. How embarrassing the performance, although each performance may not get full marks, but it is not as unbearable as the evaluation said, so I think this "Wandering Earth" is a good masterpiece
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-