It feels like as soon as "Dream of Red Mansions: A Beautiful Marriage" came out, all other film and television works about Red Mansions automatically gained one star. I complained about this movie before. At that time, I mainly thought that Guan Xiaotong's performance as Yua

I feel that as soon as " A Dream of Red Mansions: A Good Marriage " came out, all other Red Mansions film and television works will automatically gain one star.

I complained about this movie before. At that time, I mainly felt that Guan Xiaotong played Yuan Chun. It was too outrageous. Bao Dai was also either oily, ugly, or oily and ugly. I didn't dare to think about how other characters could be released.

I would spend money on other movies just for curiosity, but this is definitely not the case.

【1】

When filming Red Mansions, the audience must be most concerned about the choice of Lin Daiyu. However, this time, Daiyu is basically completely separated from the word "Daiyu", and everything is not next to each other.

Director Hu Mei broke the guard. She scolded the trolls and wanted to sue the owner. She also scolded netizens for making Daiyu look ugly and suspected of infringing on her portrait rights.

sent four more photos in succession in which she thought Daiyu was beautiful, trying to prove that Lin Daiyu was reasonable and beautiful. People who said that her vision was not good were either blind or blind.

But the question is, is this beautiful?

cannot be said to be ugly.

Zhang Miaoyi has a cute appearance. She has no problem playing the energetic girl in the sweet school drama, but anyone who sees such an appearance cannot admit that this is a qualified Lin Daiyu, right?

Hu Mei’s vision is indeed unique.

Director Hu’s state of forcing praise by pressing his head reminds me of the evaluation of Chen Xiaoxu by Wang Fulin, the director of the 1987 version of "A Dream of Red Mansions ".

Chen Xiaoxu is now recognized as the most successful Lin Daiyu and is almost her spokesperson. However, the director was not satisfied with her appearance and said "she is not beautiful enough".

Many people now mention this passage, either to reflect the high requirements of the old red building, or because they feel that the director Versailles or even pua.

But if we follow Daiyu in the original work, Chen Xiaoxu’s appearance is indeed not beautiful enough.

Many people understand Lin Daiyu’s appearance, and they may be focusing on "temperament". Cao Gong wrote that she also focused on charm, and the treatment was very vague.

However, Lin Daiyu is not an atmospheric beauty or a temperament beauty. Her beauty is not only visible to Baoyu and her sisters. People from top to bottom, of all ages and classes, with different aesthetics, think she is beautiful.

Wang Xifeng praised her for the first time when they met her, "There are really such beautiful people in the world", and was suspected of trying to please Jia's mother;

Jia Baoyu said "a fairy-like sister" when he met her for the first time, which seems to have a male lead filter.

But as a male teenager with little education, Xiaosi Xing'er said that Lin Daiyu was comparable to Xi Tzu and was full of articles. When they saw her, they were afraid to speak out for fear of blowing her away. This may be the ultimate description of beauty by ordinary people.

Not to mention that Xue Pan was "half-hearted" when he saw her for the first time. Although he felt sorry for Sister Lin, this was undoubtedly a "quantification" of her beauty.

Baoyu thinks young girls are beautiful, but a low-level and tacky person like Xue Dashu also thinks she is beautiful, so this beauty has absolute objectivity.

But why did I choose Chen Xiaoxu in the end? Because for Lin Daiyu, what is more important than beauty is the bearing, the understanding and persistence of the role.

has often said before that in the old version of the Four Great Classics, there are many actors' performances, which are almost real "fighting".

They sacrificed their souls to integrate with the character, opening up the most subtle joint, relying on this character to become famous all over the world, and then being restricted by this character, and even paid the price of real life for the rest of their lives.

From this perspective, Wang Fulin’s understanding of the characters fully respects the original work; although Chen Xiaoxu is not beautiful enough, her grace, aura, understanding, meticulous training, and exquisite clothing and makeup make her finally become Lin Daiyu.

Lin Daiyu’s calligraphy was all done by the actors themselves. Just this detail is enough to show the entire crew’s dedication. They are truly invested in creation.

[2]

Instead of making the audience crazy, Director Hu Mei might as well ask herself whether she has read the book, or simply confess like Li Shaohong that she has not read it at all, but just shoots according to her own ideas. How can I understand Cao Xueqin? "A Dream of Red Mansions"?

Because if you had read the original work carefully, you would not have chosen such actors who are dancing around with demons, and you would not have said later that the Daiyu you wanted to choose was Guan Xiaotong.

In the new "Dream of Red Mansions", Yao Di, who plays Wang Xifeng, was originally cast by Baochai. This contrast is already very confusing. In the movie version of "Dream of Red Mansions", Guan Xiaotong's performance as Yuan Chun was already stunning, but she was originally supposed to play Daiyu?

Guan Xiaotong is naturally not ugly, but she is further away from Lin Daiyu than Zhang Miaoyi.

If she were Lin Daiyu, all the other men in the drama would have to practice double-dooring and walking on stilts first.

html The plot of the 287 version of "A Dream of Red Mansions" has a lot of controversy, and the performance may not be as good as the legend. The actors' performances are mostly young and immature, and the traces of drama and stylization are also a bit heavy, but no matter how picky, the audience fully recognizes the creators and actors As long as you try your best, everyone will understand.

But if you go in the wrong direction, you will only get further and further away from the goal.

In the new "Dream of Red Mansions", the problem of serving Hua Dao and the actors is only the most intuitive. In essence, the main creator does not understand the script at all, and is extremely shallow, frivolous and arrogant.

Jia Huan is an unpopular young master, but he will never go to the kitchen to steal chicken and be chased by the cook. Because the servants in Jia's family who are a little respectable will not be short of oil and water, and people like Fangguan will even despise "greasy".

Sister-in-law Liu would not even break up with the little girls, let alone the serious young master Jia Huan, the second heir to the Rongguo Mansion (Jia Lan ranked behind him).

As for some people, this is to emphasize that the status of a common young master is not as good as a high-level servant.

First of all, please take a look at the theoretical living conditions of Jia Tanchun, a concubine with a lower status. Then you can say goodbye to the Red Mansion if your brain can only revolve around low-level house fights.

It is not suitable for you, it is not feudal for you.

In addition, there is the so-called conspiracy about Lin Daiyu’s family property. This is completely blurred in the original work. This is also Cao Xueqin’s brilliance. He does not mention it clearly and lets you think for yourself.

But some people, once they start thinking about it, they make people laugh.

made a big fuss about Jia Lian's words, "It would be nice to make another three to two million yuan in a while." They thought that the Jia family, headed by Wang Xifeng and his wife, swallowed up Lin Daiyu's family property.

In fact, the so-called "three to two million" is not three to two million taels of silver at all, but a unit of calculation of copper coins. When converted into silver, it is about three thousand taels, which can be matched by what Jia Lian said before. .

feels that three thousand taels is too little, maybe because he has read too many bills of one hundred thousand taels in other novels.

If Lin Daiyu's family really had a fortune of three to two million silver, she would not have seen the third-class servants in Jia's house and secretly marveled at their food and clothing expenses.

Some people insist that Jia Lian must have made a fortune before, otherwise he would definitely not say "make another". As for where the fortune came from, it can only be Lin Daiyu's family property.

From the perspective of oral usage habits, it cannot be completely established.

According to this logic, I am now dreaming that I want to have a 1,000 square meter villa, and if I win it, I will not pay taxes for 100 million. Are these things I have obtained before?

There must be a conspiracy in "Dream of Red Mansions", but taking these nonsense out of context and treating them as serious plots is very righteous, so don't blame it for the overwhelming negative reviews.

I originally watched "Emperor of Han Wu", " Yongzheng Dynasty ", and "Qiao Family Courtyard". They are all very classic works. The plot and disputes were very exciting. Now that I think about it, the screenwriters and actors probably contributed more.

In "Yongzheng Dynasty", director Hu Mei made the friendship between the fourth child and the thirteenth child so profound and touching, but in the film version of "A Dream of Red Mansions", the female characters were filled with unnecessary hostility towards each other.

This kind of low, dirty and aesthetically pleasing shot was actually shot by a female director. Even Chen Sicheng felt inferior to it.

In the understanding of the creators, Jia Mu despises Lin Daiyu, Wang Xifeng is more openly scheming, the little girls can directly mock Bao Dai, and Chai Dai is directly a pure love rival.No matter how great a masterpiece is, if it reaches some people, it will eventually turn into a man-stealing drama.

The director has been holding on to the so-called "beauty and ugliness". He only knows that those who complain about bad reviews are all sunspots. Why don't you explain the problem of the plot being made up and made up? Is it because you don't like it?

The movie still has 4 points, and all of us here have a responsibility.