Chen Xiaoxu, Tao Huimin, He Saifei..., who is Lin Daiyu in everyone's heart? "A Dream of Red Mansions" was released for 5 days, with a box office of 4.4 million. The box office was not ideal. It has a big director, a big IP, and a low box office. It became a hot topic for a

Chen Xiaoxu, Tao Huimin , He Saifei .... Who is Lin Daiyu in everyone's heart?

"A Dream of Red Mansions" was released for 5 days, with a box office of 4.4 million. The box office was not ideal. It has a big director, a big IP, and a low box office. It became a hot topic for a while.

The investment in this film is as high as 200 million, and it took 18 years to prepare. The director

said after the film was aired that the film had been attacked by organized "spots".

She does not accept or agree with these.

She does not agree with the argument of some viewers that the actress Lin Daiyu in this version is not good-looking enough.

Not only that, she also posted a special post, saying that an "ugly picture" that looked like Lin Daiyu's Zhang Miaoyi had been smeared by Heizi and was forged to vilify the actor.

It has not yet been determined whether this picture is of the actor himself, but the director thinks it is not because she also thinks the picture is ugly.

But some people pointed out that this picture is a screenshot from a movie and the director just forgot about it.

Netizens said, "This picture shows Lin Daiyu, played by Zhang Miaoyi, visiting the crazy Jia Baoyu before she was angry to death. The two looked at each other and giggled. How could the director forget it."

This matter has become very magical at this point.

Objectively speaking, actor Zhang Miaoyi is relatively pretty.

But the audience's requirements for "A Dream of Red Mansions " are not just pretty.

Faced with bad reviews, the director posted twice: "Hu Mei is blind? Is this sister really ugly?"

Hu Mei is a good director. She has filmed "The Yongzheng Dynasty ", "The Emperor of Hanwu" and "The Great Qiao Family" Yard" and other works.

But "Dream of Red Mansions" is extremely well-known in China, and there have been too many versions, especially after the 83 version of the classic, every version will be compared.

This kind of comparison is based on the actor's appearance and acting skills at the public level, but it is the plot logic for fans.

Let’s talk about appearance and acting skills first. There are a thousand Hamlets in the hearts of a thousand viewers, but certain objective standards do exist.

As the key character Daiyu, Zhang Miaoyi was criticized for her appearance in the play, and many viewers were not satisfied with her understanding of the role.

She said that Lin Daiyu was deviant, challenged tradition and was unique.

The Lin Daiyu she describes is not like a down-and-out young lady, but more like an 18-year-old rebellious fighter and spirited girl.

Bian Cheng, who plays Jia Baoyu, said that the biggest regret of the play is "the unfulfilled love."

The creator interpreted "Dream of Red Mansions" as a romance film. The audience was not satisfied with this interpretation of

.

The interpretation of Chen Xiaoxu in the 83 version is: "This person has seen through the things in the world."

The two people have different understandings.

Actors do not necessarily have to be highly educated, but they must at least understand the actors.

Putting aside the connotation, from a public perspective, Zhang Miaoyi's appearance and temperament do not fit well with the public's imagination of a young lady.

Wang Wenjuan once played Lin Daiyu in the Shaoxing opera "A Dream of Red Mansions". She has majestic facial features and a slightly mature look, but has a very beautiful figure.

behaves like a lady.

When all the actors stand together, you can tell at a glance who is Daiyu and who is Baochai.

At that time, Chen Xiaoxu's Lin Daiyu also received a lot of criticism. The general opinion was that she was a bit too "coquettish", but her appearance and temperament were not criticized.

In 1989, Tao Huimin also played Lin Daiyu in the movie "A Dream of Red Mansions".

She is dignified and beautiful. Although her face is plump, her expression also shows the beauty and charm of sickly beauty.

In 2010, director Hu Mei's good friend Li Shaohong filmed "The New Dream of Red Mansions", Jiang Mengjie played Lin Daiyu.

Jiang Mengjie's eyes are not big enough and a bit swollen. Although she is still a beauty overall, her Lin Daiyu only gets bad reviews.

But her eyes are somewhat similar to this version of Zhang Miaoyi.

This can't help but remind people that Hu Mei took the lead in the initial casting of "A Dream of Red Mansions" that started in 2006, but in the end, Li Shaohong took over.

Jiang Mengjie and Zhang Miaoyi are actually the same in type, and it is indeed difficult to change people's aesthetics.

In addition to the above versions, Lin Daiyu, He Saifei, Zhang Sylvia, Zhou Xuan and other stars have also played Lin Daiyu.

, but due to time and version reasons, it is not so widely spread.

But generally speaking, the actors can be regarded as beauties of an era, combining the image of Lin Daiyu with the aesthetics of the era at that time.

In perception, Lin Daiyu is not necessarily the most beautiful, but at least she is beautiful, has an outstanding temperament, and has the style of everyone.

Zhang Miaoyi is a typical Hu beauty, not a beauty in the eyes of the public.

In the "Emperor of Han Dynasty" directed by her, Lin Jing, who plays the role of the stunning beauty Wei Zifu, is actually of this type.

is not top-notch in terms of hardware, but the actor's temperament, figure and acting skills give the character a "beautiful" atmosphere.

After the incident unfolded, director Hu Mei continued to post articles discussing the actor's appearance. It can be seen that she affirmed Zhang Miaoyi's appearance.

However, the public did not buy her affirmation.

In addition to the appearance of the actors, some viewers also raised questions about the plot.

is called "the most frozen horror". After watching

, some viewers wrote a long piece of opinions.

generally has ugly art, ugly design, ugly special effects, and outrageous plot.

The director himself definitely disagrees with this evaluation.

Therefore, the director himself posted many times on social media to express his protest.

But the director didn’t buy it and it had little effect. When a

movie is made, it is a commodity, and the audience is the consumer. In a sense, if consumers don't like it, it is not good.

It can be seen from the box office that the audience voted with their feet and clearly expressed their dislike.

In fact, if the audience just criticizes with their mouths, the producers won't care too much.

" The Disappearance of Her " was criticized as vulgar, but with a box office of 3 billion, the producer was rock solid.

" All-or-Nothing " is said to be of low quality, but from a box office perspective, it is a phenomenal work, and the creators are proud to participate.

Chen Sicheng's "Tang Detective" has been said to be inferior to the other, but he is equally proud of it.

After all, as long as the box office is good enough, even if it is a super bad movie, the producer will be as stable as a rock.

However, the box office was not good. Even the great director Zhang Yimou changed his promotion strategy after the box office of " Article 20 " was not good.

Gao Ye even said during the road show that Xuanfa would listen to the advice and change the publicity strategy.

If a director as recognized as Zhang Yimou is like this, you can imagine other directors.

It can be seen that the criticism at the box office is more harmful than the complaints.

Movies are different from TV.

For ordinary viewers, there is basically no cost to watching TV programs. If they are good, they can watch them; if they are not, they can ignore them.

Even if it is criticized completely, like "My World Fireworks", the ratings are actually better, because there is no cost, and people are more willing to watch the fun.

But movies are different, movies require costs.

allows the audience to support it with real money, but it requires real ability, which is also often said to be responsible for the box office.

Generally speaking, if the audience says that a work is bad and the box office is very low, it means that the audience is consistent in appearance and does not like it.

As for the producers, whether they saw something bad and tried to save their respect, or whether they didn't know the problem at all and were incompetent and furious, only they themselves know.

Anyway, on both sides of the game, one party will always make a bad move.

Which of these Daiyus do you think is more in line with your imagination?