Even the senior sister collaboration show failed to stir up the stagnant water of "Chengfeng 2024". The two collaboration shows aired in the first half of
, "Wind Blowing Summer" were not satisfactory, but compared with "Shut Up and Dance" that Meng Jia helped sing last season, it fell far behind.
The performance version of "Midsummer" by Sa Dingding and Sit Kai-chi was not even as good as the practice room, and it can be regarded as a strange thing for this year's Sister Lang.
"Wind Blowing Summer", Meng Jia x Cai Shiyun x Yang Jinhua.
Qi Wei asked two teammates with lower personal preference rankings to participate in the cooperation show. The starting point is very good. One more stage will bring more opportunities.
However, since "China" and "Wind Blowing Summer" both involve singing and dancing, rehearsing for two stages within a week is really difficult for a layman like Yang Jinhua.
It was really pitiful to see her practicing so hard and even having an emotional breakdown.
However, the stage is the stage, and it is clear at a glance who performs well and who performs poorly.
Yang Jinhua is undoubtedly the one that Meng Jiadu can't lead. The votes for this stage are not high, and she is definitely holding her back.
The choreography and styling of "Wind Blowing Summer" are really ugly.
This Barbie color is ugly to whoever uses it.
The song itself is also mediocre, sweet but not sweet, fresh but not fresh either.
Cai Shiyun's performance is actually OK.
She has a healthy sex appeal, and such a hot dance is more suitable for her than "China".
expression management is also good, even wink does not feel awkward.
Yang Jinhua has made progress under Meng Jia's guidance, but his movements are still clumsy and lack beauty.
For example, in this panoramic view of three people, Meng Jia looks very tall and straight while Yang Jinhua looks a little hunched over in the same movement.
Although the movements of the three people were not neat, it was obvious that Yang Jinhua was several times slower.
Meng Jia’s singing and dancing ability goes without saying, but this look is really holding her back.
She is not the protagonist on this stage, she mainly provides support to the two sisters.
I personally feel that her highlight is actually in the training room.
Meng Jia is really good at teaching.
Yang Jinhua doesn’t know how to flip his hair, and Meng Jia provides on-site guidance on when to turn around and shake his head, including teaching and skills.
She also saw Yang Jinhua's demeanor when dancing.
uses "Tom Cat" to vividly indicate the correct posture.
even used "Tracker's Love" to help the two sisters remember the moves.
Although we still don’t know why the lyrics changed to "The elder brother sits on the bow of the boat, and the younger sister walks on the shore."
Meng Jia worked hard to teach, and the sisters, especially Yang Jinhua, also studied hard and practiced hard.
But as the saying goes, ten minutes on stage and ten years off stage, it is really difficult to break through yourself in a short period of time.
Generally speaking, the stage of "Wind Blowing Summer" is slightly stronger than I expected, but the flaws are still very obvious.
From the perspective of stage presentation, it is indeed a bit of a waste for Meng Jia. The stage
only received 863 votes, which was the lowest score in the first half, which probably explains something.
"Midsummer", Sa Dingding x Sit Kai-chi.
Actually, from the moment Sa Dingding decided to play, I expected that this song would not be good.
But when I watched the practice room of the senior sister's collaboration show, I regained a little hope.
Because, in the practice room version, Sa Dingding's voice matches Xue Kaiqi's voice, which is not so inconsistent.
Especially when the two of them sang together, Sa Dingding’s voice was no longer sharp or harsh.
is really a bit like what Fiona Sit Kai-chi said, the voices are very different, but the feeling of singing together is really good.
Therefore, it is inevitable that there will be some undue expectations.
But in the performance version, all my expectations were shattered by Sa Dingding’s first sentence.
I have never heard the original song, but is Sa Dingding really not out of tune?
I really don’t understand why she sings with her voice hidden.
sang to the end, even singing a sheep sound.
She clipped it, and so did Sit Kai-chi.
What's even worse is that Sit Kai-chi seems to have a bit of a tongue when singing, and her words sound vague.
Entering the chorus stage, the inappropriateness of the two people's voices became more obvious, and the more they sang, the more they sounded like they were quarreling.
This may also be adapted.
This song was originally sung by Mao Buyi, and most of his songs are in a narrating style. In the
program, Sa Dingding even made a special call to ask about Maomao's creative motivations.
Maomao said, this is a farewell song written for college graduation.
So, overall it should be a little melancholy and sad.
However, Sa Dingding and Xue Kaiqi sang so passionately and forcefully that the audience could not feel the emotion.
Maybe He Jie or Shang Wenjie could sing the duet with Sit Kai-chi, and the effect would be better.
However, compared with "Rainy Day" that Sa Dingding participated in before, this song can be regarded as a sound of nature.
Although Sa Dingding’s teammates expressed their satisfaction.
Liu Yan even spent his whole life praising Sa Dingding.
But the final vote was only 870 Chengfeng points, which is not really a high evaluation.
Of course, this is a pure singing song after all, so the score it got was already on the high side.
If I were asked to vote, I would rather vote for "Wind Blowing Summer".
"Midsummer" also has one aspect that is better than other stages - the stage design and makeup.
Although it is just a simple white wall with projected black fonts, it is simple and elegant.
After seeing the previous several fancy stages, I felt visually relaxed.
The black and white outfits also match well, especially Fiona Sit's style, which is very fairy-like and beautiful, not at all like a 43-year-old. It's no wonder that Shang Wenjie is full of praises.
I took a quick look and saw that Xue Kaiqi was born in 1981 and Sa Dingding was born in 1983. Xue Kaiqi was two years older than Sa Dingding, but she felt like she was a generation behind.
Hong Kong women are very good at taking care of themselves.
