After "I Am a Singer", which is recognized as the best music variety show in the Mainland, stopped airing, Mango was "lost" in the music variety market for a while, but fortunately "The Sound of Life" turned out. Although
Hong Kong Music Season is a gift variety show, Mango perfectly balances the relationship between music variety and science popularization, and once again takes up the banner of domestic entertainment music variety, and is praised as "Music variety, you still need to watch Mango".
After the Treasure Island season, although the lineup is far from as dreamy as netizens expected, at least the quality of the entire season is good. The song selection, arrangement, reality show, arrangement, etc. are all Mango's consistently high standards.
However, in the third season of Family Season, the complaints became more and more ugly. The audience seemed to be unable to see Mango’s sincerity. The quality of the program was high and low, and a group of good singers were wasted. To sum up, Jia Nian Hua Ji did three things wrong.
First of all, there are many points to choose from.
As a music variety show, the lineup is undoubtedly the most critical, and the program team naturally knows this. Therefore, except for Song Yaxuan, who still needs experience, all members of Family Season are good singers.
However, the program team did not provide these good singers with a good enough music library. Song selection is the most criticized issue so far.
The investment situation of Family Season is not bad, and it even still has the lineup that a top variety show should have. However, the program team is reluctant to spend money to buy song copyrights, so that many of the songs in the program are sung by Mango in other programs in the past two years. s song.
For example, "Mountain and River Pictures", "Longli Electric Silk", "Poignant Land", "But Seeking Pain", "Easy", "Suzhou River", "Walking Fish", "Falled Leaves Return to Roots", "Happiness First", etc., to say that mangoes are not "reasonable reuse" ”, the author absolutely does not believe it.
In the first episode of the Family Season, He Jiong once explained what he would sing this season and clearly proposed the line of China's century-old pop music history. However, now the program team seems to have gone back on their word, and many of the song selections have completely deviated from the main line.
It is worth mentioning that the original name of the online family season was China Season. After the Hong Kong Philharmonic Season and the Treasure Island Season, it was called China Season. The pattern of Mango is indeed worthy of praise, but fortunately the name was changed or the review failed, because this The selection of songs for this season is not worthy of the word "Chinese Season".
Secondly, reality shows are embarrassing and focus too much on traffic
Compared with Hong Kong Philharmonic Season and Treasure Island Season, the proportion of reality shows in Family Season has obviously increased, and it mainly relies on Wang Sulong, Zhou Shen and Song Yaxuan.
Especially in the first episode, these three juniors showed strong social fear, and "washing cups" became a popular meme both inside and outside the show.
But it is obvious that this is a reality show script by the program team. Song Yaxuan may be really overwhelmed when facing so many senior music industry veterans, but Wang Sulong and Zhou Shen are not like that.
fans may like to watch such scenes, but for a large number of ordinary passers-by, they are indifferent. Lin Zixiang and Ip Sian Man from the Hong Kong Philharmonic Season and Na Ying and Zhang Xinzhe from the Baodao Season are also seniors in the music industry, but Mao Buyi, Shan Yichun, Zeng Bitt, Ma Jiaqi, etc. are not afraid of being like that.
Interestingly, after Joey Yung joined the show as a flying guest, she expressed her admiration for the social terror performed by Wang Sulong and Zhou Shen. The atmosphere at that time was very embarrassing. After
reaped the benefits of this setting, the reality show in the latter part of the Family Season simply followed this route. Unfortunately, not only did it not have the same effect as the first episode, but it was called embarrassing by the audience. The guests worked hard to cooperate. The program team created a variety show-like scene, and I felt that they were very tired.
In addition, Jia Nian Hua Ji’s reality show prefers the men’s team, because the men’s team has four singers with high traffic. In addition to Wang Sulong, Zhou Shen and Song Yaxuan, the same is true for Chen Chusheng. On the other hand, the female team not only has a small number of permanent members, but only Cyndi Wang is a singer with her own traffic.
In a certain extra program, although the total duration was close to one hour, the total footage of all the women's team members did not exceed ten minutes. Fans were very angry and complained about the "preference of boys over girls" in the show.
Finally, the production is not sincere enough.
For almost every song selection in the Hong Kong Philharmonic Season, the host will introduce the background; Baodao Season has much less popular science about the selected songs, but planned a highly praised and discussed session "Please Answer".
However, Jia Nian Hua Ji does not have any outstanding small design to add points.
Of course, some viewers will say that the "mini concert" is a new highlight, but the program team did not do a good job. It always gives people the feeling of just watching the show. The singers can't sing enough, and the audience can't listen enough.
In addition, the Hong Kong Philharmonic Season and the Treasure Island Season both have reality show content about song selection and performance assignments, but the Family Season does not, so many viewers urged the program team to release this part of the content, which is much more interesting than everyone's awkward chat.
But in fact, so-called insiders have revealed that Jia Nian Hua Ji did not record this part at all. The singer and the program team communicated online most of the time, rehearsed before the recording, and left after the recording.
has come to the third season of "Continuous Sound". Compared with other domestic entertainment variety shows, it is still far ahead. Mango has indeed mastered this track.
However, if compared with Mango’s previous high-quality audio variety shows, Family Years is stretched thin. The program team can obviously do better, but it just feels like they haven’t tried their best.
Looking back on the first episode of the Home Season, even though the red song in the selection encountered controversy, there were still many viewers who supported it. What’s more, Mango’s concept and layout are so amazing that other platforms can’t match it. It is no different from the subsequent programs. In comparison, it is completely high and low.
