's recent criminal investigation dramas "Criminal Punishment" and " Ice Rain and Fire " are in full swing.
" Punishment " has a Douban score of 7.2, neither high nor low, a good criminal investigation drama drifts in the direction of ethics. What is the difference between
and Douban's 9.2-point criminal investigation drama ceiling " The Silent Truth "?
01 The cast is equal, the protagonist's acting skills, Bai Yu is slightly better
The cast of "Punishment" and "Silent Truth" are very strong, and there are many old actors.
"Punishment" has Zhao Xiaosheng as Cheng Yu, Li Youbin as Yan Guohua, Yang Youning as Zhao Pengchao, Wang Yang as Zhao Pengcheng...
"Silent Truth" Liao Fan as Yan Liang and Ning Li plays Zhang Chao, Tan Zhuo plays Li Jing...
The fairy fights, it is difficult to be exciting, and the supporting characters on both sides are strong and have great acting skills.
They not only performed characters in the play that were far away from their own appearance and temperament, but also conquered the audience with their plastic-shaping acting skills.
As for the starring role, Huang Jingyu of "Punishment" can't hold back the powerful old actors around. His acting skills appear impulsive and weak, lacking emotional layers and coincidental tension.
and "Silent Truth" Bai Yu plays Jiang Yang, a high-spirited and high-spirited student in the early stage, and the image of a sunny and young prosecutor is unobstructed.
Ke Dang has suffered many hardships, and vividly interprets the vicissitudes and helplessness, inferiority and self-esteem, pain and helplessness after being released from prison.
, especially the "Pingkang Three Heroes", finally got together to clean up Jiang Yang, who had just been released from prison. As a result, he burst into tears the moment he learned that he had lost his wallet. This scene really touched people, and almost everyone cried together. .
hit me all at once, and I can't help myself.
and Jiang Yang decided to sacrifice themselves in order to make their death arouse the public's attention. Before committing suicide,
muttered:
"I have really tried my best, I have tried my best, we have all tried our best."
Bai Yu showed Jiang Yang's transformation from a prosecutor with a bright future to being framed as a prisoner, and then to a desperate fighter, the external and internal mental state and the complex emotions mixed in it, fully displayed to the audience. In front of us, we were moved, and we couldn't help but follow the protagonist in grief and anger, tears together, and hopeless hope together...
drives the audience's emotions and thoughts, which is also one of the evaluation criteria for a good drama. Low, at a glance.
02 The villains are really strong, but the frontal forces are disparate
"Punishment", the Zhao family headed by Mr. Zhao Zhao Xiaosheng and his four sons, together with 54 protective umbrellas, make the Zhao family cover the sky in Changwu with one hand, monopolize the real estate, Mining, logistics, aquatic products and other industries.
The whole city of Changwu is covered with clouds.
The task force headed by Chang Zheng, the vice-captain of the Criminal Investigation Brigade, stared at the Zhao family, found the flaws in the Zhao family, and wiped them out.
Although Li Bodong, the deputy captain of the Criminal Investigation Detachment, and Xiao Zhenbang, the deputy director of the Public Security Bureau, are internal ghosts, every time there is a breakthrough in the case or there is new evidence and witnesses, Zhao will be arrested.The family was informed that evidence was destroyed and witnesses were killed.
But as long as the protagonist Changzheng is framed or hurt, the secret investigation team will send someone to rescue him in distress.
Chang Zheng was framed for the first time because of the yacht explosion. Jin Yan rescued him from the airport in time and cooperated with him to find evidence to prove his innocence; The black cat shot, Chang Zheng's life was at risk. At this time, political commissar Yan also called Zhao's undercover Qiu Tao to save Chang Zheng in time;
In the third case of Cao Dalong's murder, Chang Zheng was framed, and the secret investigation team and the prosecutor helped him wash Get rid of suspicion.
I don't know if it's the protagonist's halo, the backstage is hard enough, or the secret investigation team is strong. As long as Chang Zheng is in danger, someone will save him. Although Jiang Yang of
"The Silent Truth" is the protagonist, he is not as lucky as Chang Zheng. Instead, he appears more real, just like you and me among thousands of people, without background or backstage, just a bit of a lonely hero.
Jiang Yang's villains are also very powerful: the Kahn Group headed by Hu Yilang, Li Jianguo, the captain of the criminal investigation team, Qin Dachuan, the former mayor of Qingzhou City, his son-in-law Zeng Xiangdong, the murderer Xia Dongping, and whoever is behind Big tiger.
colluded with official business gangsters, traded power and money, and started with a thirteen-year-old girl, which was too bad to be outrageous.
When Hou Guiping came to teach in this barren land full of enthusiasm, death quietly approached him.
When he was teaching, he accidentally discovered that the female middle school students in the class were taken to the sensual venue by the gangsters to give to the officials and businessmen.
He insisted on justice and was unwilling to join forces with the bad guys. He wanted to reveal the unbearable truth to the public. He was framed and raped by the villain. After he was silenced, he was thrown into the river.
Jiang Yang was entrusted by his classmate Li Jing, and at the instigation of his girlfriend Wu Aike, he began to investigate the case reluctantly. After slowly learning the truth, he fell deeply into it, unable to extricate himself, and insisted on overturning the case for Hou Guiping, for the victim Speak up and sacrifice for justice.
As the case progressed, Jiang Yang met like-minded friends, policeman Zhu Wei and forensic doctor Chen Mingzhang, to form the "Pingkang Three Heroes" who confronted the powerful villains.
Every time they get a clue or come into contact with a witness, and there is a major breakthrough in the case, the evidence will be destroyed and the witness killed or disappeared.
When Jiang Yang and his wife and children were threatened, they were forced to divorce without help. When
was framed for corruption and bribery, Zhang Chao, his defense lawyer, was also put together and sentenced to three years in prison.
was a postgraduate prosecutor with a bright future. In order to maintain his belief in justice, he gave up his girlfriend at the time and sacrificed his youth, marriage, career, reputation and self-esteem.
And his chief prosecutor, for the sake of his own safety in his later years, deliberately concealed important evidence, and did not hand over the photos to Jiang Yang until he retired.
Although Chief Prosecutor Wu is not the villain, he is also an accomplice, fueling the arrogance of the bad guy.
, like his daughter Wu Aike, is prudent and selfish, and both are exquisite egoists.
Jiang Yang after his release from prison, the vicissitudes and haggard visible to the naked eye, may have suffered physical and mental damage in prison.
In just three years, the spirited and capable prosecutor has become a little rickety and even diagnosed with advanced lung cancer.
Even if he loses everything, even his life, he must seek justice in the dark. He is the faint light in the dark.
In the end, Jiang Yang decided to fight with his death.
and reckless have beenZhu Wei, who took off his police uniform, Chen Mingzhang, who went to Shanghai to provide financial support, lawyers Zhang Chao, Li Jing, and reporter Zhang Xiaoqian, who were also the only victims left at the time, planned the earth-shattering case together.
attracted the public's attention and the attention of the upright criminal detective Yan Liang, presented clues and evidence, finally broke the vicious circle of silence and uncovered the truth.
3. "The Silent Truth", even if the villain ends up committing suicide in fear of crime, or being arrested, it is hard to settle.
"Punishment" has not yet reached the finale. With the development of the plot, it is estimated that the Zhao family will be arrested and the umbrella will be wiped out in one fell swoop;
bad guys will be punished by the law.
Changzheng's criminal investigation team and the secret investigation team led by Political Commissar Yan will both be commended, which is a happy ending.
"The Silent Truth" is adapted from "The Long Night Is Difficult" by Zijin Chen . Isn't the fate of the protagonists the same as the long night?
Jiang Yang and Hou Guiping have gone through seven years and paid countless prices, even risking their lives for the "judicial relay", which has caused many audiences to cry.
There is no good news for good people, especially Jiang Yang's feeling of sadness and sadness, which makes people feel distressed and complains against him.
In ten years, some people have changed, some people haven't.
Jiang Yang has never changed, and the more setbacks he is, the firmer he is, vowing to give justice to the world.
In the past ten years, Zhang Wei and Chen Mingzhang have silently supported him, they are peers.
Finally, after he gave everything, someone was moved, Zhang Chao, Li Jing, Zhang Xiaoqian chose to stand up.
can plan all this, restore the truth, and adhere to justice for a group of people who did not get a good ending, or died or died, and the rest will suffer in prison, with a maximum sentence of seven years.
is really hard to understand, although the argument is more than love, but there are also light sentences for making up for faults or criminal motives.
The person who finally broke the silence of the truth did not get the medal, and even Hou Guiping and Jiang Yang did not have the rehabilitative footage, and they became silent victims.
If the ending is a little more human, the score will be higher. The 0.2 I deducted is a protest against the ending of "The Silent Truth".
"The Silent Truth" does not have the twists and turns of "Punishment" as to the process of solving the case and the reversal of the plot, but it is solidly moved and thoughtfully focused on the hearts of the audience.
"Most of us will be the silent majority when something is unfair.
We won't be accomplices, but we can't be like the protagonist who will do whatever it takes for justice, but we are deep in our hearts Everyone admires such a hero.
We may not all be able to become Jiangyang, but there is a Jiangyang in our hearts.”
As the author said.
