Detective Di Renjie can be said to be the most successful detective drama. There are four consecutive dramas, and each Douban score is above 8 points. After that, few detective dramas can achieve such high quality, and the Tang Dynasty Weird Story is one of the few. Although
are both detective dramas, there are actually many differences between the two.
Detective Di Renjie mainly focuses on the case of Duke Di, Li Yuanfang is always in a subordinate position as a super-powerful combat force, Zeng Tai, who only say that adults are really gods, didn't play a big role, Di Gong's Official Di Chun is almost a soy sauce. In short, in the whole play, Di Renjie's status is overwhelming, and the whole investigation process basically relies on him to reason alone.
Tang Dynasty The Weird Stories is different. It is true that Su Wuming, a disciple of Di Gong, is responsible for his IQ, but Lu Lingfeng's importance is above him. Lu Lingfeng is not only strong in martial arts, but also thoughtful, arrogant and self-respecting but kind. Although he is not as perfect as Li Yuanfang, he can also be called a generation of heroes. The role of the genius doctor Fei Ji Shi is also indispensable. He is not only the funny person in the whole play, but also rescued Lu Lingfeng with medical skills many times at critical moments. It is not an exaggeration to be regarded as the strongest assist. The heroine Pei Xijun is good at painting, and the case of Shiqiao Tu provides her with key clues. In short, this is a detective team, and everyone is important.
In addition, the cases of detective Di Renjie are almost all major cases related to national economy and people's livelihood. Princess Tang attempted to subvert Wu Zhou's conspiracy, and it was only through Di Renjie's deductive reasoning that he was able to see through the clouds.
The case of Tang Dynasty Weird Stories so far does not involve feelings of family and country. It looks strange and complicated on the surface, but it is basically a worldly grievance and hatred. The mastermind of the Chang'an black tea case was hopeless in his career, the mastermind of the Gan Tangyi case wanted to steal money, and the mastermind of the stone bridge pattern was unwilling to die. Pull people to do back pads. It is a matter of opinion as to which subject is more appealing.
Of course, the detective Di Renjie is not without flaws. The flashbacks to analyze the case are too long, and the reversal of the plot shows a routine. Every time the villain thinks he will win, he will reveal the conspiracy. Take one step and succeed. The more you see it, the less the surprise after the reversal.
In addition, the detective Di Renjie's language has a strong tendency to be written. If it weren't for Liang Guanhua , Zhang Zijian and others with solid lines, the average actor really couldn't control it.
However, in terms of reasoning, it is obvious that the detective Di Renjie is stronger. Di Renjie's reasoning is almost meticulous, observant, and logical, and people have to be convinced. The real murderer who finally appears is often unexpected, but reasonable. What's more, almost all the reasoning is original by the director Qian Yanqiu , which is really shocking.
The reasoning of the Tang Dynasty conspiracy case is relatively rough. Generally speaking, in order to maintain the mystery of the plot, who is the real murderer is always deciphered at the end, but even if you don't see the end of the story, you can infer who the real murderer is. For example, the boss of the Chang'an Black Tea case is a person with poor legs and feet in a wheelchair. It just so happens that the county magistrate limps when he walks, which is very obvious. Huang Mei's murder case is easier to guess. Almost all the people who appeared on the stage are dead, only the beggar Donglang and the handyman Jixiang are left. Among them, Jixiang gives a lot more shots. He likes reading and hunting. The answer is already Self-explanatory. Although
is slightly inferior in terms of judgment and reasoning, the Tang Dynasty Weird Story also has its own characteristics. Its plot moves fast. Only 20 episodes have been broadcast so far, but the fifth case is about to be decrypted. On average, one case is solved in four episodes. Many trivial descriptions that can be omitted in the middle are omitted. Compared with Di Renjie, the story of the Tang Dynasty has also made great progress in terms of serving the Tao. It looks beautiful and has a film-like texture.
In short, both dramas are very good detective dramas.If you have to choose a winner, it is naturally the detective Di Renjie. But the story of Tang Cao's Weird Stories has just been broadcasted halfway, and the later plot may be more exciting, and this judgment may also be broken. In a word, The Story of the Tang Dynasty is definitely the best costume drama in recent times, there is no one.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-