On November 14, #阿信concert’s singing skills were questioned again# was trending on Weibo, attracting attention. According to media reports, Mayday held a concert in Shanghai on November 12. The band's lead singer Ashin and JJ Lin collaborated to perform "A Song for No One". Durin

On November 14, #阿信concert’s singing skills were questioned again# was trending on Weibo, attracting attention.

According to media reports, on November 12, Mayday held a concert in Shanghai. The band's lead singer Ashin and Lin JJ collaborated to perform "Song for No One". In the chorus part, Ashin's voice broke and went out of tune, but he quickly adjusted and continued to complete the performance. This scene attracted widespread attention on the Internet, and many netizens questioned Ashin's live singing skills.

Some music professionals and fans also stood up to defend Ashin. They pointed out that "Song for No One" has a higher vocal range, and Ashin chose the original tune of JJ Lin to sing. This arrangement itself increases the difficulty. In this case, some minor mistakes are understandable.

Some viewers also suggested that they should not rely solely on video clips to judge the performance of the entire performance, but should make an evaluation after fully understanding the actual effect of the entire concert.

Despite this, the discussion on social media about Ashin’s performance is still very intense. Some netizens expressed their support for Ashin in a humorous way, but there were also some criticisms. Some netizens believe that as a senior singer, Ashin should show higher stability and should not lower his requirements due to age and other factors.

According to previous media reports, on December 3, 2023, a blogger once broke the news that 5 of the 12 songs at the Mayday concert were lip syncs. The blogger selected 12 songs taken by fans at the concert and extracted Human voices are analyzed. According to his judgment, among the 12 songs, "Cheers", "Love", "Contented", "My Lover Is Missing", "Sad People Don't Listen to Slow Songs" are lip-synced, and the first few lines of "Write This Song for You" are fake. Yes, the latter is true.

Subsequently, according to CCTV news, the original video and audio of the "Mayday" Shanghai concert have been submitted to the local cultural market inspection department. The relevant departments will conduct a scientific evaluation and analysis of the provided audio and video content and publish the investigation results. In May 2024, the Law Enforcement Team of the Shanghai Municipal Culture and Tourism Bureau stated that it had not found any "replacement of live singing or performance" at the Mayday Shanghai concert, and introduced the entire process of how to supervise the Mayday Shanghai concert, how to obtain evidence, and how to identify it.

Source: Beijing time

Reporting and rights protection channels: Download the "Morning Video" client from the application market and search "Help" for one-click access; or add reporting customer service on WeChat: xxcbcsp; or call the hotline 0731-85571188. If you need content cooperation, please call the government and enterprise service desk at 19176699651.